Dan Walters

Dan Walters

Dan Walters: Prop. 37's labeling requirements are especially perplexing

Published: Monday, Oct. 29, 2012 - 12:00 am | Page 3A
Last Modified: Tuesday, Feb. 26, 2013 - 8:16 pm

This year's ballot contains a number of highly complex measures but none is as bewildering as Proposition 37, which purports to provide Californians with information about genetically modified foods.

Even a conscientious voter who reads the voter's pamphlet and follows news coverage can be confused by the welter of claims and counterclaims.

"Proposition 37 is a simple, common sense measure," proponents tell voters in the pamphlet. "It doesn't cost anything to include information on a label, and it's phased in, giving manufacturers time to print new labels telling you what's in the food, or change their products if they do not want to sell food produced using genetic engineering."

"Prop. 37 isn't a simple measure, like promoters claim," opponents counter. "It's a deceptive, deeply flawed food labeling scheme that would add more government bureaucracy and taxpayer costs, create new frivolous lawsuits, and increase food costs by billions – without providing any health or safety benefits. And, it's full of special- interest exemptions."

The Legislative Analyst's Office, which is charged with giving voters a plain- language summary of every ballot measure, does its best to explain what Proposition 37 would, and would not, do. But it's limited, because in reality no one knows how it would be implemented or what the ancillary consequences would be.

Elementally, it's a market battle between the organic food industry and traditional food producers and sellers. Those two factions have put up most of the campaign money, with the latter outspending the former perhaps six- or sevenfold.

But the downright weird wording of the measure, with myriad definitions and exemptions, appears to set legal traps, giving lawyers who specialize in class- action lawsuits a vast new territory to explore, much as occurred with Proposition 65, a 1980s-vintage measure requiring signs for products and locales with even the slightest connection to cancer.

Indeed, one of the drafters of Proposition 37 is a lawyer who was instrumental in Proposition 65, thus lending credence to arguments about its being legal quicksand.

The opponents also say that passage would trigger sharp increases in our food costs because California would be the only state with such a labeling requirement, thus requiring manufacturers to make California-only products, but that's speculation because no one knows whether they would change their products' content or just place new labels on them were it to pass.

The measure is sufficiently off-putting that almost every major news- paper in the state has urged rejection, some arguing that labeling, if warranted, should be done nationally rather than in a single state.

This is one measure that should give voters particular pause.

© Copyright The Sacramento Bee. All rights reserved.

Read more articles by Dan Walters

Dan Walters, political columnist

Dan Walters

Dan Walters has been a journalist for more than a half-century, spending all but a few of those years working for California newspapers. At one point in his career, at age 22, he was the nation's youngest daily newspaper editor.

He joined The Sacramento Union's Capitol bureau in 1975, just as Jerry Brown began his first governorship, and later became the Union's Capitol bureau chief. In 1981, Walters began writing the state's only daily newspaper column devoted to California political, economic and social events and, in 1984, he and the column moved to The Sacramento Bee. He has written more than 7,500 columns about California and its politics and his column now appears in dozens of California newspapers.

Email: dwalters@sacbee.com
Phone: 916-321-1195
Twitter: @WaltersBee

Sacramento Bee Job listing powered by Careerbuilder.com
Quick Job Search
Sacramento Bee Jobs »
Used Cars
Dealer and private-party ads


Price Range:
Search within:
miles of ZIP

Advanced Search | 1982 & Older