Dan Walters

Dan Walters

Dan Walters: Tax break flap lands in California's Capitol

Published: Monday, Apr. 29, 2013 - 12:00 am | Page 3A
Last Modified: Monday, Apr. 29, 2013 - 6:20 am

Twenty years ago, as California struggled to emerge from what was then the worst recession since the Great Depression, then-Gov. Pete Wilson and the Legislature enacted a tax break to spur capital investment in job-creating small businesses.

The new law allowed investors in firms with no more than $50 million in assets and that had 80 percent or more of those assets and their payrolls in California to pay only half of the ordinary state income taxes on profits when they liquidated their investments.

Within a few years, California saw a boom in high-technology startups. The capital gains tax break played some role, although how big is uncertain.

In 2004, the state Franchise Tax Board disallowed a capital gains exemption claimed by Newport Beach resident Frank Cutler on his investment in a technology company six years earlier, and Cutler took the dispute to court.

Last year, Cutler won his case in the 2nd District Court of Appeal, which ruled that limiting the tax break to investments in California businesses of a certain size was an unconstitutional interference with interstate commerce.

Cutler's aim was to expand the tax break's reach, but late last year, the Franchise Tax Board went the other way, declaring not only that the 1993 tax law was invalid, but that those who benefited from its provisions would have to repay their tax savings for the previous four years.

It was a grim Christmas present for several thousand California investors who would be dunned for about $120 million, plus interest and penalties in retroactive taxes. It came just a month after voters had raised income taxes on high-income Californians that also would be retroactive for 2012.

Not surprisingly, those who were targeted for the restorative capital gains taxes screamed that it was unfair since they had just followed the state's own law. They organized themselves into a political lobbying group and began pressing both the FTB and the Legislature for relief.

The angry taxpayers appear to be gaining political traction. The FTB has put collection of the back taxes on hold, implying that it wants the Legislature and Gov. Jerry Brown to solve the problem.

A couple of bills have been introduced with bipartisan support to re-enact the tax break with modifications and to relieve the affected taxpayers of paying back taxes.

Occurring, as it did, just as the state was raising its top income tax rates, the retroactive capital gains tax issue has garnered national financial press attention, calling into question, once again, whether California's tax policies discourage job-creating investment.

Ironically, it arises as the state is struggling to emerge from another recession that's even deeper and longer-lasting than the one that spurred the capital gains tax break in 1993.

Call The Bee's Dan Walters, (916) 321-1195. Back columns, www.sacbee.com/walters. Follow him on Twitter @WaltersBee.

© Copyright The Sacramento Bee. All rights reserved.

Read more articles by Dan Walters

Dan Walters, political columnist

Dan Walters

Dan Walters has been a journalist for more than a half-century, spending all but a few of those years working for California newspapers. At one point in his career, at age 22, he was the nation's youngest daily newspaper editor.

He joined The Sacramento Union's Capitol bureau in 1975, just as Jerry Brown began his first governorship, and later became the Union's Capitol bureau chief. In 1981, Walters began writing the state's only daily newspaper column devoted to California political, economic and social events and, in 1984, he and the column moved to The Sacramento Bee. He has written more than 7,500 columns about California and its politics and his column now appears in dozens of California newspapers.

Email: dwalters@sacbee.com
Phone: 916-321-1195
Twitter: @WaltersBee

Sacramento Bee Job listing powered by Careerbuilder.com
Quick Job Search
Sacramento Bee Jobs »
Used Cars
Dealer and private-party ads


Price Range:
Search within:
miles of ZIP

Advanced Search | 1982 & Older