Dan Walters

Dan Walters

Dan Walters: Does spending more boost education outcomes?

Published: Sunday, May. 26, 2013 - 12:00 am | Page 3A
Last Modified: Wednesday, May. 29, 2013 - 8:28 am

Gov. Jerry Brown's plan to change how K-12 schools are financed – giving more money to districts with large numbers of poor and/or English-learner students – faces criticism on several points.

One of them, often voiced by those in suburban districts, is that the current formula shouldn't be changed until schools reach some overall measure of financial adequacy.

The measure varies, depending on who's talking, but it's usually the national per-pupil average.

A new Census Bureau report on school spending, including federal funds, tells us what that would mean.

The report says California schools spent an average of $9,139 in direct operational costs on each of its 6.2 million students in 2011, not counting capital outlay and other ancillary expenses.

That $9,139 is about $1,400 under the national average and less than half of top-spending New York's $19,076. California was 36th among the 50 states and the District of Columbia, with Utah lowest at $6,212.

In other words, California would have had to spend another $8.8 billion in 2011 to meet the national average, or roughly what we spent on prisons.

Matching New York would have cost $61.6 billion, more than doubling what California was spending.

Economically, reaching the average would not be a huge burden. School spending was just 3.6 percent of Californians' personal income in 2011, seventh lowest in the nation, and another $8.8 billion would add just a half-percent.

Politically, however, it would be difficult. Californians already have the nation's fifth highest overall tax burden.

The numbers raise another issue. Would a sharp increase in school spending, all by itself, generate significantly better outcomes?

Examining the Census Bureau report side-by-side with a recent federal Department of Education report on 2011 high school graduation rates reveals no correlation between spending and educational success.

New York spent more than twice as much per pupil as California, but its high school graduation rate, 77 percent, was virtually identical to our 76 percent. Washington, D.C., schools were slightly below New York in spending at $18,475, but had the nation's lowest graduation rate of 59 percent.

Conversely, the highest graduation rates, approaching 90 percent, were found in states with moderate rates of spending. Utah, dead last in spending, had the same 76 percent rate as California while Texas, which fell just below California in spending, had an 86 percent rate.

An adequate amount of money is obviously important. But just money, it would appear, isn't a magic bullet. Other factors, such as poverty, speaking English, culture, teacher quality and parental involvement, are evidently just as important.

Our political debate over education, however, almost never gets past money.

Call The Bee's Dan Walters, (916) 321-1195. Back columns, www.sacbee.com/walters. Follow him on Twitter @WaltersBee.

© Copyright The Sacramento Bee. All rights reserved.

Read more articles by Dan Walters

Dan Walters, political columnist

Dan Walters

Dan Walters has been a journalist for more than a half-century, spending all but a few of those years working for California newspapers. At one point in his career, at age 22, he was the nation's youngest daily newspaper editor.

He joined The Sacramento Union's Capitol bureau in 1975, just as Jerry Brown began his first governorship, and later became the Union's Capitol bureau chief. In 1981, Walters began writing the state's only daily newspaper column devoted to California political, economic and social events and, in 1984, he and the column moved to The Sacramento Bee. He has written more than 7,500 columns about California and its politics and his column now appears in dozens of California newspapers.

Email: dwalters@sacbee.com
Phone: 916-321-1195
Twitter: @WaltersBee

Sacramento Bee Job listing powered by Careerbuilder.com
Quick Job Search
Sacramento Bee Jobs »
Used Cars
Dealer and private-party ads


Price Range:
Search within:
miles of ZIP

Advanced Search | 1982 & Older