Lauren Carroll / The Associated Press

Carolina’s Mike Tolbert, looking for yardage against Atlanta’s Robert McClain last month, said the host Panthers’ status as underdogs against the 49ers gives him “a bad taste in my mouth.”

Underdog role offends some Panthers

Published: Friday, Jan. 10, 2014 - 8:56 pm

Carolina Panthers fullback Mike Tolbert said he’s always been shorter, fatter and slower than the next guy.

He plays with a chip on his shoulder and runs as hard as he does because he’s had that underdog mentality since he’s played football, he said.

So when the Panthers – at 12-4 with a first-round bye, playing in front of their home crowd against a San Francisco team they beat earlier in the season – were picked as the underdog in Sunday’s playoff game, Tolbert felt disrespected.

“I can’t speak for everybody else, but personally, yes, I do,” Tolbert said. “To me, it’s absolutely ridiculous why we’re the underdogs at home when we’re 7-1 at home, when we beat teams that are in the same caliber as San Francisco, if not better. Personally I got a bad taste in my mouth about it.”

The Panthers opened as a consensus one-point favorite in sports betting books early this week. As of Friday evening, San Francisco was the consensus one-point favorite. The Indianapolis-New England game is the next closest line, and the consensus has the Patriots as a seven-point favorite.

Several other Panthers, including defensive end Greg Hardy, said they didn’t care what Las Vegas or talking heads had to say about Sunday’s game.

“If you don’t stop me, I’m going to break your quarterback’s face,” Hardy said. “If he doesn’t throw it to (his) receivers, he’s not going to win. It depends upon who’s in the position and who wants to make the plays. It doesn’t matter what team is hot, what team is up or down, what team’s feeling sorry for themselves, what team’s the favorite. Hell, I ain’t been a favorite in 24 years. I’m doing great.

“That’s just people talking. Naysayers, people jabbing, even old analysts and old players talking about a game that they’re too slow to play. Congrats to them. That’s what they get paid for.”

Conventional wisdom would give the Panthers an edge based on the home field, but recently that hasn’t been the advantage it once was in postseason play. According to, teams hosting divisional playoff games won 56.3 percent of the time from 2005 to 2012. From 1990 to 2004, home teams won 81.7 percent of the time.

One mortgage resource company picked the 49ers to win Sunday because teams from the city with the higher mortgage rate went 4-0 in the playoffs last week. San Francisco’s 4.68 percent rate bests Charlotte’s 4.54 percent rate.

Panthers coach Ron Rivera suggested Friday that one of the reasons San Francisco is favored is because of the 49ers’ playoff experience. The 49ers have been to the NFC Championship Game in each of the past two seasons and are coming off a win in Green Bay, where visiting teams historically have struggled to win.

Rivera said he doesn’t mind going in with an underdog mentality.

“I think the thing that we all have to understand is it’s going to come down to the actual playing of the game. For whatever reason, people want to put labels on whether you’re the favorite or the underdog. That’s a part of it,” Rivera said.

Missing from the first 49ers-Panthers game was wide receiver Michael Crabtree, who was recovering from an Achilles’ injury. Crabtree caught eight passes for 125 yards in the 49ers’ victory against Green Bay last week.

Also, tight end Vernon Davis didn’t play in the second half against Carolina after suffering a concussion at the end of the second quarter. Those two additions have some pundits siding with the 49ers this time.

“Their best receiver to me is Vernon Davis, and he tapped out of the game,” said cornerback Drayton Florence, who added he doesn’t care who picked the 49ers to win. “With that said, Crabtree is a great receiver. He’s been a great addition to them, another weapon to throw the ball to, but we just got to put our hands on him at the line of scrimmage.”

Florence is part of a Panthers secondary that has felt disrespect this season as more attention has been given to Carolina’s formidable front seven. Free safety Mike Mitchell said he wasn’t surprised at the perceived lack of respect this week because he has dealt with it all season.

“We embrace the role. It doesn’t mean it’s right,” Mitchell said. “You don’t ever let other people tell you who you are. You know who you are.

“We like it, though. The thing is they say these things, but we like it because it’s easy motivation for us.”

Read more articles by Jonathan Jones

Sacramento Bee Job listing powered by
Quick Job Search
Sacramento Bee Jobs »
Used Cars
Dealer and private-party ads


Price Range:
Search within:
miles of ZIP

Advanced Search | 1982 & Older