Ben Margot / Associated Press

Giants catcher Buster Posey watches the Dodgers' Nick Punto hit an RBI double during L.A.'s seven-run fifth inning.


Is baseball right in protecting its catchers from home-plate collisions?

Leading off: Protecting catchers makes good sense

Published: Tuesday, Feb. 25, 2014 - 10:49 pm

Baseball is a tough game, and among its toughest players are catchers.

A new rule going into effect in the major leagues this season protects catchers – to a great extent, not completely – from unprotected collisions at the plate.

Why protect these guys wearing shin guards, chest protectors, cups, helmets and masks? Why take away what traditionally has been a sometimes intimidating part of the baserunners’ arsenal? Is baseball going soft?

No. The sport’s keepers are acknowledging modern realities, some physical, some common sense and some financial.

Thirty years ago, players such as Dave Parker were baseball rarities, huge, fast men whose physiques stood out among the relatively slighter builds of players who preceded the weight-room era. Now, even smaller players are built like running backs, meaning just about every player rounding third presents a threat to catchers waiting to handle throws – rarely one-hop perfectos – with arms outstretched and the baseline roughly bisecting their stance.

Even the toughest linebacker could be undressed in an unprotected collision with a 200-pounder at ramming speed.

The cost of such collisions has become prohibitive, too. Good catchers are hard enough to find and develop, great ones rarer still. Nobody – catchers, teammates, the players’ union, owners – wants these guys vaporized for the sake of an old-school macho ethos. Plays at the plate are exciting enough without injury.

Big-league catchers won’t say so – because they are, you know, catchers – but one can bet they see wisdom in a move that will help keep them on the field and more or less in one piece.

– Brian Blomster

Today’s poll

Is baseball right in protecting its catchers from home-plate collisions?

• Yes, it makes sense

• No, it’s a part of the game

Vote above, or go to

Tuesday’s results

If the 49ers’ head-coaching job opens, whom should they hire?

• Vic Fangio: 10%

• Greg Roman: 15%

• David Shaw: 45%

• Jim Tomsula: 15%

• Other: 15%

Total votes: 200

Read more articles by Brian Blomster

Sacramento Bee Job listing powered by
Quick Job Search
Sacramento Bee Jobs »
Used Cars
Dealer and private-party ads


Price Range:
Search within:
miles of ZIP

Advanced Search | 1982 & Older