Renee C. Byer /

A photograph of Natalie Giorgi, 13, who died from an allergic reaction to peanuts in July 2013, sits in the State Capitol as her mother Joanne Giorgi came to support Senate Bill 1266 on Wednesday April 02, 2014 in Sacramento, Calif. The Bill would increase the prevalence of emergency epinephrine auto-injectors, or EpiPens, in California schools. Joanne Giorgi told lawmakers Wednesday that access to the medication could help other children. "You will save a life," she told the Senate Education Committee, which voted without dissent to move the bill forward. View a photo gallery.

Editorial: Battle over EpiPens in schools pits politics against kids’ safety

Published: Friday, Apr. 4, 2014 - 12:00 am
Last Modified: Sunday, Apr. 6, 2014 - 10:26 am

Anaphylaxis is a severe allergic reaction triggered by a variety of things, from getting stung by a bee to eating just one nut. It comes on quickly and can kill a person in a few minutes.

Kids are at special risk, as many have unrecognized allergies. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention estimates that as many as 6 percent of all children have a food allergy. Thanks to technology, however, we have medicines and medicine-delivery systems, such as epinephrine auto-injectors, that can counter anaphylaxis in just as immediate a fashion.

Current state law allows children with diagnosed allergies to keep their prescribed epinephrine auto-injectors, commonly known under the brand name EpiPen, at school in case of a reaction. It’s a good law, but it leaves out all the children who have no idea whether they have severe allergies.

Senate Republican leader Bob Huff of Diamond Bar has a bill that would fix the oversight and require schools to keep a stock of epinephrine auto-injectors and train some school personnel to use them in an emergency. But this potentially lifesaving legislation is being fought by teachers unions unhappy with the shifting of duties from school nurses to teachers.

In a Senate Education Committee hearing Wednesday, Kendra Harris, a lobbyist for the California Federation of Teachers, said her organization’s members “are concerned that they are being asked to do more and more medical care to students that goes far beyond their training and their general job responsibilities.” Then she urged state leaders to increase the amount of nurses and health care professionals working full time in schools.

That lament is understandable; blocking a good-sense measure that might prevent children from dying for the sake of a pipe dream is not.

From the viewpoint of children and their families, there’s virtually no downside to having a ready supply of epinephrine auto-injectors on hand at school with people trained on how to use them. EpiPens and their ilk are easy-to-use, spring-loaded injectors that deliver a pre-measured dose of epinephrine. As a nurse and doctor explained during Wednesday’s hearing, non-medical professionals can be easily trained to recognize a severe allergic reaction. Also, misdiagnoses don’t pose the same danger as other medication, such as insulin for diabetics. Epinephrine, otherwise known as adrenaline, is naturally occurring in human bodies and causes the heart to beat very rapidly for a short time.

Moreover, the bill would not require all teachers to administer epinephrine auto-injectors, only those who volunteer for training.

Still, Huff’s staff expects a battle for this legislation at the next two Senate hearings, then again in the Assembly. That’s based in part on this week’s hearing and letters of protest from the CFT, the California Teachers Association and the California School Employees Association, and in part on the experience of a similar bill three years ago allowing school personnel to give anti-seizure medication to children. It passed, but the unions also opposed it on the grounds that it would be better to have nurses administer it.

It would great to be able to afford school nurses again. But the reality is that the state barely has enough money to pay teachers and keep schools open as it is. Fortunately, there is lifesaving technology and medicine that can help mitigate that lack. If only politics can get out of its way.

Read more articles by the Editorial Board

Sacramento Bee Job listing powered by
Quick Job Search
Sacramento Bee Jobs »
Used Cars
Dealer and private-party ads


Price Range:
Search within:
miles of ZIP

Advanced Search | 1982 & Older