Dishing the news about the Sacramento area food scene

As Vic’s Ice Cream expands, let’s revisit the Vic’s vs. Gunther’s blind taste battle

12/03/2013 10:49 AM

12/03/2013 10:50 AM

The Bee’s Claudia Buck has some scoop in today’s Business section about expansion plans for Vic’s Ice Cream, a venerable Land Park institution for icy treats and lunch counter fare. According to the story, Vic’s will add an adjacent cafe which will serve Temple Coffee’s caffeinated brews and pastries from Old Soul.

Look for the upcoming Vic’s Cafe to open by the end of December.

This news makes us think back to summer, when The Bee tried to settle one of Sacramento’s great food arguments: Who makes the better ice cream - Vic’s or Gunther’s?

This blind taste test was conducted in a spirit of fun, but we did our best to create reliable test methods and assemble a well-rounded tasting panel. (That panel, pictured above, included Darrell Corti, Ella pastry chef Jane Anderson, and kids of course!)

But in the end, one old fashioned ice cream shop reigned supreme: Gunther’s, which bested Vic’s in three out of four categories.

Though December isn’t exactly ice cream weather, let’s harken back to those summer days. Our online poll is still open for readers to vote for their own favorite, so put the Thermos of soup down and click here.


* Gunthers vs. Vic's -- which ice cream is best?

* Vic’s Ice Cream expands, adding a new coffee cafe

About This Blog

Appetizers brings you the latest restaurant happenings, interesting tidbits on good food and events, and -- of course -- great specials and deals.

Regular contributors

Chris Macias
Food and wine
Twitter: @chris_macias

Allen Pierleoni
Counter Culture
Twitter: @apierleonisacbe

Debbie Arrington
Food and cooking
Twitter: @debarrington

Blair Anthony Robertson
Restaurant reviews
Twitter: @blarob

Key links

Dining reviews
Restaurant guide
Mike Dunne's wine picks
Beer Run
Nosh Pit
Restaurant inspections

Join the Discussion

The Sacramento Bee is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere on the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Terms of Service