Sacto 911

Covering crime, police and courts in the Sacramento region

Plumas jury finds man guilty of murder in 20-year-old’s shooting death

09/27/2013 7:59 PM

10/19/2013 8:13 AM

The day after a Plumas County jury found Gregory Chad Wallin-Reed guilty of murdering Rory McGuire, the victim’s mother said the world seems different, if ever so slightly.

“Everything seems a little brighter. … I feel like justice was served,” Carol Starzer said Friday.

The jury of 10 women and two men needed less than three hours to find Wallin-Reed, 38, of Reno, guilty of first-degree murder in McGuire’s shooting death.

They convicted him of seven additional felony counts that include firing at an occupied vehicle, five counts of assault with a deadly weapon, and possession of an illegal assault rifle.

Plumas County Superior Court Judge Ira Kaufman put the verdict in jurors’ hands Wednesday afternoon. They reached a decision Thursday morning.

As the court clerk read the verdict, Starzer wept quietly. It’s been two years and two months since her 20-year-old son’s death, “and now it’s over,” she said Friday.

Plumas County District Attorney David Hollister said he was particularly pleased that Starzer and Dave McGuire, the victim’s father, could enjoy “some sense of justice from this tragedy.”

Richard Young, Wallin-Reed’s defense attorney, said he was disappointed by the verdict. He is considering an appeal or a motion for a new trial, he said.

The case against Wallin-Reed stems from a July2, 2011 chase from his remote cabin near Janesville along back roads leading toward Antelope Lake. After Wallin-Reed caught a carload of six men stealing a solar light from his property, he pursued the vehicle driven by McGuire for eight miles, firing as many as 26 shots at it.

When McGuire missed a road that would have taken him to the lake, he turned his car around in a meadow, where it came to a stop. Wallin-Reed approached the car and fired into it.

Investigators found a total of 12 cartridges from an assault rifle and seven from a handgun, according to testimony during the trial.

McGuire, of Susanville, was shot in the head and died two days later. Wallin-Reed also shot two other occupants in the lower legs.

In his defense, Young argued that Wallin-Reed was standing his ground and protecting his family and property. The law allows pursuit of an assailant until the danger is past, and Wallin-Reed fired at the vehicle only after someone in it fired at him, Young said.

Investigators found no gun in McGuire’s vehicle.

Hollister said the case was challenging but that the month-long trial, which attracted a film crew from NBC’s “Dateline,” could not have gone any better.

“If people were thinking Plumas County would be a bunch of bumpkins, they were disappointed,” he said.

Wallin-Reed, who was surrounded by armed officers throughout the Thursday proceedings, showed no expression as the court clerk read his verdict.

He is scheduled for sentencing Nov.21. The minimum sentence for his first-degree murder conviction with enhancements is 50 years to life, Hollister said.

Sacto 911 Staff

Bill Lindelof

Cathy Locke

Andy Furillo
Superior Court

Denny Walsh
Federal Court

More Sacto 911


Send news tips

Sign up for breaking news alerts

Arrest Logs

Crime Q&A

Sacramento Bee reporter Cathy Locke answers your questions about crime news, trends and issues. Look up specific cases using Arrest Logs and Sacramento Superior Courts case database.

Submit your question


Join the Discussion

The Sacramento Bee is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere on the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Terms of Service