Sacto 911

Covering crime, police and courts in the Sacramento region

Federal judge orders improved conditions for mentally ill death row inmates

12/10/2013 5:19 PM

12/11/2013 7:33 AM

A federal judge in Sacramento ordered state prison officials Tuesday to continue working to improve treatment for seriously mentally ill inmates on San Quentin’s death row, but did not give inmates’ attorneys sweeping changes in the care of their clients.

In a 28-page order, U.S. District Judge Lawrence K. Karlton told state prison officials to work with the court-appointed special master overseeing mental health care in “an assessment of unmet need for inpatient care in the condemned inmate population at San Quentin.”

Karlton also ordered prison officials to consider creating a hospital unit for condemned inmates, at either San Quentin, the California Medical Facility in Vacaville or the newly opened prison hospital in Stockton, but he did not order them to do so.

The judge found that the state still is not meeting Eighth Amendment requirements for adequate treatment of seriously mentally ill inmates. He noted that some improvements have been made, but that there is no simple answer to the problem.

“The solution is not, however, clear from the record before the court,” Karlton wrote.

Michael Bien, lead attorney for the inmates, said late Tuesday, “The most important thing is the judge found there remains a constitutional violation, and the state has to do a better job.”

The judge added that Tuesday’s order further demonstrates that he was right in denying an earlier motion by the administration of Gov. Jerry Brown to terminate the long-running class action on behalf of mentally ill inmates.

Bien also said that Tuesday’s order bolsters the prisoners’ opposition to the state’s pending appeal of Karlton’s refusal to terminate the lawsuit.

The order stems from a motion filed by attorneys for the inmates last April seeking improvements in mental health care, as well as changes in how the use of force is deployed against mentally ill inmates.

Karlton has yet to issue an order on the use-of-force issue.

State corrections spokeswoman Deborah Hoffman said the state is committed to providing adequate mental health care to its inmates and will continue working to do so.

Sacto 911 Staff

Bill Lindelof

Cathy Locke

Marissa Lang

Darrell Smith
Superior Court

Denny Walsh
Federal Court

More Sacto 911


Send news tips

Sign up for breaking news alerts

Arrest Logs

Crime Q&A

Sacramento Bee reporter Cathy Locke answers your questions about crime news, trends and issues. Look up specific cases using Arrest Logs and Sacramento Superior Courts case database.

Submit your question


Join the Discussion

The Sacramento Bee is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere on the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Terms of Service