Comfort foods help ease cold and flu season
12/20/2012 12:00 AM
12/20/2012 12:26 PM
It's that time of year. The nights are long, the mornings are chilly, and rain-soaked days test our resolve. Maybe you're sniffling and sneezing, coughing and clammy and ready to be done with your all-too-common cold.
Wouldn't it be nice if you could have a bowl of soup, a cup of tea or box of chocolates and make it all go away?
OK, so maybe the science is shaky on this one, but that nourishing bowl of chicken noodle soup or tender, chewy ramen swimming in spicy-hot broth just might make you feel better while your symptoms run their course.
Nate Simon, a Sacramento physician, is both a man of science and a devout foodie, but on this topic he is a bit of a party pooper.
Asked if he has a go-to restaurant dish or two to help with his cold symptoms, Simon, an anesthesiologist, was prepared: "The science is not good enough to pinpoint specific foods."
He pulled out all kinds of facts and studies. We stopped short of wondering if he believes in Santa Claus.
"There's no silver bullet," he continued. "A lot of the cures or remedies are anecdotal."
Simon says most colds are "self-limited," meaning they're going to swoop in, inflict damage upon your nose and throat and then vacate the premises in a matter of days.
"You could say, 'I ate this food and felt better.' But you could also say, 'I wore green socks and felt better,' " he said.
Still, the doctor advises that it's perfectly OK to gravitate toward comfort foods when you're ailing. They're nourishing, they probably inspire pleasant memories, and, more than likely, these foods have healthy ingredients.
"For some reason, I really like Korean and Japanese food" when ailing, he said. "Warm rice dishes and soups."
At Harry's Cafe, there's a soup so good it practically comes with a guarantee. Harry's "cold or flu" chicken vegetable soup seems to fix everything but your tax problems. He uses ginger, pepper and dry herbs to give the broth a kick of heat.
"I made that soup for myself before I even opened the restaurant," said owner Harry Luong. "It works for me. When I have a cold, I want something to make me sweaty and make me feel better. That's why I wanted it a little spicy.
"Everybody loves it. Everybody comes back when they have the cold or flu and they feel better right away. All the hot stuff takes the toxins out of the body."
Along those lines, I tend to order a large bowl of the tan tan men at Shoki Ramen House when I'm dragging. Maybe the science doesn't support it, but I always feel peppy and clear-headed by the time I'm finished. A meal in itself, I order it "extra hot." If you ask for "super hot," the toxins may leave via the tears streaming down your cheeks.
For dessert, whether ailing or not, you might drop by Ginger Elizabeth Chocolates. If you're going to indulge in wishful thinking, why settle for a sugar-pill placebo when you could have a seductively simple square made of bittersweet chocolate ganache from Venezuela or a chewy caramel infused with French lavender and sprinkled with a pinch of fleur de sel? Dark chocolate has antioxidants. That much we know.
"Chocolate makes you feel better mentally," said Ginger Elizabeth Hahn, a formally trained chocolatier. "Polyphenols exist in chocolate. It's the same chemical in your brain that's released when you fall in love. It's more of a mental cure for people's stress."
Also, chocolate's melting point is the same as the human body's temperature, meaning nature intended it to melt on your tongue – slowly, until your cold goes away.
Hot tea, civilized and soothing, is an age-old way to tackle colds. Tea manufacturer Traditional Medicinals, which calls itself "a pioneer of the wellness tea category," is famous for such blends as "Throat Coat" and "Nighty Night." The company recently launched a new line of teas made with organic "super plants" like fennel, ginger, nettle leaf and roasted dandelion root.
Locally, tea is more popular during the cold and flu season. At Temple Coffee & Tea's three locations, you can get your fix for under $5.
Owner Sean Kohmescher says the most popular teas for colds are chamomile and peppermint.
"A better tea that people don't pick that often is a high-grade white or green tea," he said. "They've got a lot more nutrients in them."
Dianne Hyson, a nutrition professor at California State University, Sacramento, opts for tea and orange juice when she's sick. She's not counting on them to cure her cold, but she knows the ingredients might play a role in relieving symptoms. The juice also evokes pleasant memories of what she consumed as a child.
"If you take it purely on a scientific point of view, it's hard to find things that prevent colds or make you feel better in the short term," Hyson said. "Because we are human, it's hard to untwine the science-mind connection. Our mind does influence how the science works in our bodies.
"I wouldn't discount the fact that having a hot, steaming bowl of soup would help us feel better, but there's nothing in that soup, scientifically, that does that."
Joshua Lurie-Terrell is dialed in to the local food scene. He says he suffers year-round "from horrible allergies, and I get colds and sinus infections in the winter."
He could go to the drugstore. He could see a doctor. Or he could consume some soon dubu, a Korean stew with silky tofu in a spicy red pepper broth. He orders it at Pine Tree House.
"The tofu cools down and cuts the spice quite a bit," Lurie-Terrell said of the eating experience. "When they're in your mouth together, you get all the flavor of the spice and the benefits of it clearing out your sinuses – without the pain. It's very soothing."
And sometimes soothing is all the science a body needs.
Soothing food remedies
2026 16th St., Sacramento
"Cold or flu" chicken vegetable soup
Shoki Ramen House
Two Sacramento locations:
2675 24th St.
1201 R St.
Tan tan men (ramen and broth)
Pine Tree House
9205-D Folsom Blvd., Sacramento
Soon dubu (Korean stew with tofu)
Ginger Elizabeth Chocolates
1801 L St. Suite 60, Sacramento
Assorted chocolates, three kinds of hot chocolate
Temple Coffee & Tea
Three Sacramento locations:
1010 Ninth St.; 2829 S St.
2600 Fair Oaks Blvd. suite 101
4960 Freeport Blvd., Sacramento
"Challenge" ramen in a garlic broth
Pho Ha Vietnamese Restaurant
6175 Stockton Blvd., Sacramento
Pho (Vietnamese broth) Muntean's Sandwiches and Soups 1225 J St., Sacramento
More than a dozen soups
Join the Discussion
The Sacramento Bee is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere on the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.