Gov. Scott Walker of Wisconsin and his wife, Tonette, had planned to spend a recent Friday night at the Nashua home of Jennifer Horn, the New Hampshire Republican chairwoman.
Then he heard about Al, the Horns’ beloved Dalmatian-Catahoula Leopard mix.
The dinner was promptly moved to a restaurant in nearby Bedford. “The governor’s allergic to dogs,” Horn said “And we have a very hairy dog.”
The attention to Walker’s likely candidacy for the Republican presidential nomination has focused on weighty matters such as his battles with the left, faltering forays into foreign policy and conservative stances on social issues including abortion and gun rights. But little notice has been given to an area in which he faces a different sort of constitutional challenge: overcoming his aversion to man’s best friend.
Jeb Bush can lament how he lost a Labrador (named for his brother Marvin) to cancer. Marco Rubio has a Shih Tzu, with a name like a gift from heaven: Manna. Ted Cruz goes one better: His rescue mutt is called Snowflake. (“Dear Jesus, please, please, PLEASE bring us a puppy,” his daughters prayed, according to Cruz’s Facebook page.) And if Walker makes it to November, he could face Hillary Rodham Clinton and her toy poodle, Tally.
Walker, who gives a gloomy stump speech filled with “worry,” perhaps could use a four-legged image softener of his own. But he is allergic to dog dander, an aide confirmed.
And in that, he is running against the long sweep of U.S. political history.
If the ritual for presidential candidates wooing American voters had a handbook, “must love dogs” would be somewhere near the front.
At the Newseum in Washington, the “First Dogs: American Presidents and Their Pets” exhibit is listed as “on display indefinitely.” On the National Mall, the memorial to Franklin D. Roosevelt depicts his Scottish terrier, Fala, forever at his feet.
Puppy love in presidential campaigns dates at least to Herbert Hoover, who loosened up his stiff image by posing, paws in hands, with King Tut, his Belgian Malinois, on the way to victory in 1928.
“It humanizes them,” said Claire McLean, the founder of the Presidential Pet Museum. “It shows that they are just like me and you, with the kids and the dog.”
The potential contenders in the 2016 field are quick to offer furry proof of their humanity. Clinton and Tally posed in People magazine. Vice President Joe Biden shows grade-schoolers photographs of his dog Champ.
The list goes on. Martin O'Malley, a former Maryland governor, has Rex, a cocker spaniel, and Winston, a mutt. Gov. Rick Perry of Texas has a dachshund, a black Lab, a mutt and a Griffon named Duchess. Ben Carson, a retired neurosurgeon, has a German shepherd named Echo; former Sen. Rick Santorum has spent the last year mourning his own shepherd, Schatzie.
Even candidates who are not dog owners strongly hint that they intend to become dog owners: a spokeswoman for Bobby Jindal said he “likes dogs!” and was looking to get one when he leaves the Louisiana governor’s mansion.
Walker’s allergies prevent such a possibility, a situation that his spokeswoman called “unfortunate because he loves animals.” (In fairness, Walker, who had a fish growing up, is not the only allergic White House aspirant: The children of Gov. Chris Christie of New Jersey also had to settle for a goldfish.)
In a possible sign of his will to win, Walker has managed to suppress his allergic reactions in the past. In 2010, during his initial run for governor, he greeted Lisa Bell, a Republican activist who had been tossing her wire fox terrier, Diva, in the air during his speech. Bell recalled that Walker was “very nice” to the dog and “pet her.”
Perhaps to compensate for his difficulty, Walker has reached out to more exotic animals. “He did the bear encounter and giraffe encounter,” said Judith A. Domaszek, who runs Wildwood Wildlife Park in Minocqua, Wisconsin, which Walker visited last summer. She said he petted and fed fruit juice to a kinkajou, a small mammal often called a honey bear.
“He had no problems there, and they have lots of dander,” Domaszek said.
While earlier presidents preferred horses or birds - William McKinley’s Mexican parrot was said to be named Washington Post - dogs have a more storied presidential history.
Warren G. Harding’s Airedale, Laddie Boy, had his own chair at Cabinet meetings. Republicans accused FDR of sending a destroyer to the Aleutian Islands to pick up Fala, who had his own secretary. Richard M. Nixon may have saved his spot on the Eisenhower ticket in 1952 with his televised speech focusing on his daughters’ cocker spaniel, Checkers. And Lyndon B. Johnson appalled reporters by lifting his beagles, Him and Her, by their ears.
Candidates would be unwise to try that. It was often noted in 2012 that Mitt Romney once drove from Boston to Canada with the family Irish setter, Seamus, on the roof of the car.
Seamus survived. But presidential dogs have met their ends in poignant ways. Abraham Lincoln’s Fido, a yellowish-brown mongrel, was killed by a knife-wielding drunk not long after the president’s assassination.
George W. Bush’s dog Spot had a series of strokes, and Bush communed with her on the South Lawn, stroking her head to say goodbye before having her put down.
Recent presidential dogs have been important supporting characters for the first families, and their names often seem out of central casting.
Ronald Reagan had Victory, Rex and Lucky. Years later, amid the fallout of the Monica Lewinsky scandal, Bill Clinton’s Buddy was the “only member of our family who was still willing” to keep the president company, Hillary Clinton later wrote. (Post-presidency, Buddy was run over by a car in Chappaqua, New York.)
Recent history provides a possible solution to Walker’s pooch problem. In 2009, Sen. Edward M. Kennedy gave President Barack Obama a low-dander Portuguese water dog, who was named Bo; the president’s daughter Malia, like Walker, has allergies. But the president is considered to be less fond of his family’s dogs than his children are.
He also seemed annoyed at a fundraiser last year in Greenwich, Connecticut, when he said a donor’s dog “got hair all over my pants.”
But Obama quickly added: “He is an adorable dog.”
Likewise, said McLean, of the Presidential Pet Museum, Walker would be wise to deflect attention from his allergy.
“Nobody would let on if they didn’t like dogs,” she said, matter-of-factly.