Editorials: End secrecy in California’s groundwater logs
07/08/2014 12:00 AM
07/07/2014 4:07 PM
California is the only state in the western United States that does not regulate groundwater at the state level.
Worse, as Sacramento Bee reporter Tom Knudson pointed out in a Sunday story, “As drought persists, frustration mounts over secrecy of California’s well drilling logs,” the state also is unique in the West with a wrongheaded, outdated 1951 law that makes well logs and drillers reports confidential information and not available to the public.
That makes real groundwater management impossible.
All other western states make well logs open to the public, many on the Internet. California should do the same.
Sen. Fran Pavley of Agoura Hills introduced legislation, Senate Bill 263, in 2011 that would have made the information available to university researchers and other groundwater professionals, but it got so watered down that Gov. Jerry Brown vetoed it.
“The original intent of this bill recognized that wise management and use of groundwater supply requires public disclosure of well logs,” Brown wrote. “Unfortunately, as amended, this bill now unduly restricts the use of these reports and imposes severe criminal penalties for disclosure.”
Pavley came back in 2012 with Senate Bill 1146 to grant full public access to well logs. It failed.
During the current drought, with reports of severe overdrafting of groundwater, Pavley, Assemblyman Roger Dickinson of Sacramento and the governor’s office have committed to work together to produce a groundwater management bill by August.
They are working through issues that have been contentious since the drought of 1976-77, such as requiring local entities to develop groundwater management plans, and if they fail to do so, having the state step in.
But, to date, the Dickinson and Pavley bills do not mention repeal or amendment of Water Code Section 13752, the statute that prohibits public disclosure of well logs.
A working group is scheduled to meet in the governor’s office today. Public disclosure should come up, and it should be included in the legislation.
The timing is right. The California Groundwater Association, which represents well drillers and opposed disclosure in the past, has shifted. “By and large, we are much more amenable to making (well logs) available,” Executive Director John Hofer told Knudson.
That should include public reporting on actual pumping from individual groundwater wells, which is needed to manage any groundwater basin.
The Bee’s editorial board in April called for legislators to extend reporting of pumping “to the whole state, no exceptions, and require public release of the information.” That, too, should be in the legislation.
Opponents fear, rightly, that transparency would raise questions about who’s pumping how much and where.
That would be the point. Public disclosure is key to real groundwater management.
Join the Discussion
The Sacramento Bee is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere on the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.