Dan Morain: Zombie debt rises, 18 years later
08/03/2014 12:00 AM
08/03/2014 12:19 AM
On behalf of Cascade Capital LLC Series A, Convergent Outsourcing Inc. sent me a letter telling me I had past-due balance of $455.86.
I had never heard of Convergent, or Cascade. But the notice got my attention, and that of my wife, who asked whether there was something I should tell her. No, sweetheart, it’s a scam.
“Our client has advised us that they are willing to settle your account for 35 percent of your total balance due to settle your past balance,” Convergent’s letter said, offering me a deal. “Your settlement amount would be $159.55 to clear this account in full.”
I called the 1-800 number, and a person named Lillian answered by informing me that the call was being recorded.
“How can I assist you?” Lillian asked politely. “This is an attempt to collect a debt.” She politely requested the last four digits of my Social Security number, my home address and my phone number. I politely told she must be joking.
There must be a mistake, I said, and asked to talk to Lillian’s supervisor. Oh, and I’m taking notes in an attempt to write a newspaper column.
“Bear with me one moment,” Lillian said, placing me on hold. “The supervisor is in a meeting at this time.”
Please have her call, so we can resolve this, I said. Of course, Lillian said, and “you have a great day, sir.”
In 2011, debt collectors retrieved $55 billion in past-due debt, an amount that is rising as the economy improves and people buy more stuff. A report issued by the Urban Institute last week detailed by McClatchy’s Kevin G. Hall says a third of Americans have past-due debt.
The bulk of that is debt people owe, and presumably should pay. Then there is the netherworld I encountered of zombie debt. With massive thefts of credit card information, Social Security numbers and other personal details, we’re all at risk for identity theft and fraud. Debt, as I learned, can rise from the dead.
There is big money to be made in debt. In May, Silver Oak Services Partners, a private equity firm based in Illinois, sold its stake in Convergent and boasted that during the years when Silver Oak owned Convergent, Convergent’s business grew by 35 percent.
Conveniently, Convergent’s new owner, Account Control Technology Holdings Inc., services student loans, including debt in the name of one of my kids, meaning me. Convergent and other debt collectors business will only grow as more students struggle to repay five- and six-figure loans that collectively exceed $1 trillion.
Cerberus Capital Management, the giant private equity firm chaired by former Vice President Dan Quayle, helped finance ACT’s takeover of Convergent. Cerberus has been in the news for orchestrating the $9.2 billion sale of Safeway to Albertsons, and in the past was in the news for having owned gunmaker Remington Arms. Guns, groceries and debt collection help make the world go ’round.
In 2011, Sen. Mark Leno, D-San Francisco, got the notion that the debt industry needed more regulation, and that collectors shouldn’t be able to sue to collect debts from consumers who don’t owe the money.
Leno heard many tales of woe as he carried his legislation. There was, for example, the story of the schmoe named Lou Correa who had run afoul of a debt collector in Orange County.
Then there is the Lou Correa who is Leno’s seatmate. Probably the most conservative Democrat in the state Senate, Sen. Correa might have opposed Leno’s bill. But the Senate staff told him that his wages were going to be garnished, and he became Leno’s co-author. The moral: If you’re a debt collector, chose your Lou Correas carefully.
In the 2 1/2 years between February 2011, when Leno introduced his first version of the bill, and July 2013, when Gov. Jerry Brown signed the bill into law, the California Association of Collectors and Encore Capital Group, the nation’s largest debt buyer, donated $258,283 to California campaigns.
The collectors and Encore contributed $148,900 in the three prior years, 2008, 2009 and 2010. The point: when lawmakers sought to impose greater regulation, the collections and debt-buying industry responded by donating at least $110,000 more to legislators’ campaigns. Collectors collect from us and legislators collect from collectors. It’s all very symmetrical.
Back to the letter offering to settle a debt I don’t owe. In 1995 or 1996, someone stole a credit receipt and used it to buy fancy sunglasses and ran up $455.86 in charges. My bank canceled the card and assured me that I owed nothing, and I forgot about it.
Every few years, however, the debt rises from the dead, and I get notices telling me to pay. It’s called zombie debt. Finally, I decided to solve the mystery.
I never did hear back from Lillian’s supervisor. But I did chat with Tim Collins, a Seattle attorney who represents Convergent, and explained how it was that I received the letter requesting that I pay $455.86, or settle the debt for $159.55.
Banks and retailers outsource their debts by bundling them and selling them to debt buyers, such as Cascade.
Cascade, which is based in Petaluma, pools the money of investors seeking a return on their money and buys past-due debt for pennies on the dollar. To collect on the debt, it hires a debt collector, such as Convergent.
“This seems to happen,” Collins said. “Accounts that shouldn’t have been sold are being sold.”
He stated the obvious: “You should never pay a debt you do not owe.” He noted that some people, not wanting the hassle of dealing with a dent on their credit reports, would write a check.
Cascade owner Lee Brockett told me “the creditor doesn’t know” that a debt is bogus.
“It is incumbent on the consumer to clarify,” Brockett said.
In other words, Cascade and Convergent invaded my mailbox with a threatening notice about a debt I don’t owe and claim it’s “incumbent” on me to tell Cascade to bug off.
And, he added, “We usually want the dispute put in writing.” Brockett said he would waive the requirement that I put my dispute in writing. But I insisted on writing. So here goes: People shouldn’t buy things they can’t afford. Nor should people steal credit information. Debt collectors should know the difference.
About This BlogDan Morain has been a columnist at The Bee since 2010 focusing on state government and politics. He previously worked for The Los Angeles Times covering the California Supreme Court when Rose Bird was chief justice, the Legislature when Willie Brown was speaker and the governor's office during Gray Davis' tenure. Dan Morain can be reached at email@example.com or 916-321-1907. Twitter: @DanielMorain.
Join the Discussion
The Sacramento Bee is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere on the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.