« Finale fate |
| Don't cry for 'Me'-linda »
May 17, 2007
'Idol' shocker
Fox/Frank Micelotta
Judge Simon Cowell didn't take his own advice Wednesday night.
Week after week, he has reminded front-running "American Idol" contestant Melinda Doolittle to accept all her accolades without looking "shocked and surprised."
However, when she was eliminated at Wednesday's results show, after more than 60 million votes were cast, even Simon was stunned. As for Melinda, she maintained her composure, smiling and hugging finalist Blake Lewis (shown above) and getting through her farewell song, "I'm a Woman."
The "Idol" audience - and I'm guessing pretty much anyone else nationwide who was watching - was "shocked and surprised." That's because Melinda's offing was as stunning - maybe even more so - than rocker Chris Daughtry going home last season at No. 4. Ironically, Wednesday night's show featured a performance by Elliott Yamin, who left in 2006 at No. 3. And, with a new album out and a tour about to start, Melinda got a glimpse at what her future could hold.
Let's face it, she'll still do great.
That said, it will be Jordin Sparks and Blake in a sing-off on Tuesday. For their part, both contestants absorbed the Simon shock factor. Blake even gave Melinda his bouquet of flowers.
After the show, Simon voiced his frustration, saying "I backed Melinda because I thought she was the best singer. It's just frustrating."
No question, Jordin, 17, will assume the front-runner's spot. She'll likely pull in many or most of Melinda's votes. Blake, 25, certainly will hold his own, though his quirkiness might not be as appealing as Jordin's cuteness.
Wednesday night's show was opened not by host Ryan Seacrest but by none other than Homer Simpson, who quipped, "Is it too late to vote for Fantasia?" ("The Simpsons' " season finale is this Sunday.)
I caught a glimpse of contestant Lakisha Jones, who was eliminated last week, and No. 12 contestant Brandon Rogers in the audience. Both are back in L.A. to prep for next week's big showdown.
Believe it or not, there wasn't a ton of goofy filler. There was no visit to the farmers market, and the Ford commercial happened so fast I can barely remember it. What viewers did get was how the Final 3 spent their one day back in their hometowns.
Jordin went to Glendale, Ariz., where she visited her high school, made radio and TV appearances, and reunited with her best friend of 15 years, Bailey.
Blake, back in Bothell, Wash., sang with Sir Mix-A-Lot, went to his parents' home and performed the National Anthem at a Seattle Mariners game.
Melinda headed to Nashville, Tenn., where she drank a lot of "sweet tea." She also made an appearance at her church.
Elliott's performance was fun because it was the first time he had returned to the "Idol" stage. Afterward, the judges gave their thoughts (which Elliott really didn't want to hear).
Randy Jackson: "That was hot. I'm happy you came home."
Paula Abdul: "I'm speechless and so proud of you."
Simon: "It was great to have you back."
Elliott's advice for the contestants? "Just exude a great sense of pride. Be proud of yourself. It's only the beginning of great things to come. Good luck to all of you."
There also was a performance by Maroon 5. On Tuesday, Blake sang one of the group's songs. Wednesday night, I thought he could easily have jumped into the lead singer's shoes.
Meanwhile, back to Melinda's departure and the judges' reactions. Randy told her she has "nothing to be ashamed of." Paula said, "Do your career. It will be huge."
Simon, well, he's still in shock.
Check back to this space later today for a Q&A with Melinda.
Posted by Leigh Grogan at May 17, 2007 08:35 AM
| 
