American Idol Blog archives

BACK TO THE AMERICAN IDOL BLOG HOME PAGE

April 30, 2007

Sparking concern

Associated Press

Jordin Sparks (above) is all the "American Idol" buzz today. Two things in particular:

* Many of her fans have been so concerned because she was the last contestant left standing last week - even though none of the six was in jeopardy - they're rallying to keep her truly protected this week, when two contestants will be eliminated Wednesday night.

According to Yahoo! Buzz, contestant Blake Lewis is this week's top-searched "Idol," but Jordin received a 75 percent rise in online searches, up to No. 2. Lakisha Jones got a boost, too, possibly because it was assumed she was a likely candidate for eviction had not the "Idol" producers gotten so charitable.

Is this the "spark" that Jordin needed? Well, as I blogged last week, if the scenario gets sympathy votes for Jordin, then she probably has nothing to worry about.

* What Jordin might need to concern herself with is a blog item posted
at clydestuff.blogspot.com that refers to her MySpace page not being her actual MySpace page. Got that? According to "Clyde," he received an e-mail that may or may not have come from Jordin's mom, Jodi Sparks, saying the image of Jordin holding a "Stop Abortion Sign" - as well as other stuff on the Web site - weren't hers because it's not her page.

The e-mail purports to say that yes, while Jordin is pro-life, the contestants' blogs/MySpace pages were taken down early in the season to avoid just this sort of thing. I had gotten that firsthand from Chris Sligh, who was eliminated at No. 10. He told "Idol" reporters that he was told to take down his blog while he was still on the show to avoid what I call the "Antonella Barba Bust," where inappropriate photos of that Top 24 contestant were posted all over cyperspace, with her friends saying the really raunchy ones weren't of Antonella at all.

Again, what does this mean for Jordin? Probably nothing. Even though Season 5 contestant and local girl Mandisa got caught up in wrangling over her religious beliefs last year, Jordin isn't nearly as vocal. I've never even heard her mention the word abortion. And, unless I'm missing something, "American Idol" is still a singing competition, right?

Posted by Leigh Grogan at 02:03 PM | Comments

April 27, 2007

'Idol' thoughts

McDonald's

Well, I'll be glad when things get back to "normal" - whatever normal is - on "American Idol" next week. The musical genre is rock, and Jon Bon Jovi is the mentor.

Meanwhile, there seems to be some concern among Jordin Sparks' fans that, because she was the last contestant safe on Wednesday, she somehow earned the lowest number of votes.

Lisa Pray of Sacramento e-mails: "Do you think that Jordin really had the least amount of votes this week? It would seem to be the case, as she was the last person to get the good news. I thought the method they used to tell her (and us) was just plain cruel. It wouldn’t have ruined the show to let us all know right away that no one would be going home.

Also, I think this pumps up the motivation for fans to vote for Jordin. Since she was seemingly last in the vote-getting, her fans will be super-motivated next week to make sure she stays on the show. That may not be fair to the other contestants. Don’t get me wrong, I’m a huge Jordin fan. I think 'American Idol' messed up on this one."

I heard the same comments from other "Idol" fans who are gearing up for a big vote for both Jordin and Chris Richardson, who was safe right before her. But, best I could tell, host Ryan Seacrest said the contestants would hear their fate in no particular order. So I don't necessarily believe these two were the bottom vote-getters.

Was it cruel to keep them - and us - in the dark? Well, the "Idol" brain trust loves the word "shocking," so that about sums it up.

Interestingly, I caught Fox's "Reality Remix" show Thursday night, and the contestants had their own thoughts about everyone being told they were safe.

Lakisha Jones said she didn't know what the plan was. "I prepared mentally to go home," she said. "I was in the bottom two last week, so I was ready."

Phil Stacey piped up that Melinda Doolittle told him she thought they all would be safe.

"She was saying how come we all were rehearsing the last song ("American Prayer") if one of us was leaving the show?" he said. "That's when we got suspicious."

Not that the contestants aren't delighted to all be safe - for now.

Jordin, who was crying real tears after hearing she was safe on Wednesday, said she was trying to put the results scenario together as the show unfolded.

"Every elimination night there's pressure," she said. "Actually, I was happy that Chris was staying, even if it meant I was going home."

In other "Idol" news:

* The big cut: While the Top 6 weren't eliminated on Wednesday's star-studded "Idol Gives Back" show, two big names were. According to E! Online, the night was so jam-packed with star power, two hours weren't enough to fit everybody in. Taped segments featuring Pink and former "Idol" guest coach Gwen Stefani were reportedly trimmed from the broadcast and will air instead on an upcoming episode of the show.

* Get happy: Get yourself - or your kids - to McDonald's because, through May 10 with the purchase of a Happy Meal or Mighty Kids Meal, diners will receive a superstar toy inspired by "American Idol."

Season 5 contestant Paris Bennett (shown above) helped launch the happy campaign. Some of the toys include Starry-Eyed Shades, an MP3 toy, Star Guitar, Popstar Headset, the Applause-O-Matic and the Judgmental Mic (my personal favorite).

Just curious: How old is too old to purchase a Happy Meal?

And, even though I'm not - sniff - going to the Season 6 finale, there's a chance you could. If you click here, you can enter to win the "You're Going To Hollywood" sweepstakes. Two winners will receive a trip for four next month to see the winner crowned.

Posted by Leigh Grogan at 10:53 AM | Comments

April 26, 2007

Get ready to rock!

This just in: Jon Bon Jovi (shown left in an AP photo) will be the mentor for the Top 6 contestants, who will have more than their share of pressure to perform to, well, rocker status on Tuesday. That's because two of the six will be eliminated on Wednesday's results show.

The show will combine votes from this week with what comes in next week to determine the bottom two.

I've been reading other postings about the fact that Wednesday night's show didn't turn out to be an actual results show, other than 70 million votes were cast and a ton of money was raised for "Idol Gives Back."

The word "fraud" popped up a couple of times. Others thought the charity campaign should have been a separate event from the singing competition. And several folks were quick to hit me with an "I told you so!" Let me know what you think.

Hey, now the Top 6 get to spend one more week together in their "Idol" bubble.

Back to Wednesday night's show - almost 24 hours later, I'm still wondering why the show's producers didn't have more past "Idol" finalists on. I would have liked to see Chris Daughtry and Elliott Yamin from last season.

Meanwhile, the numbers are still trickling in. The "Idol" PR team reports that the two-night special, which concluded with Wednesday night's star-studded gala, has already raised more than $60 million (and counting). A final figure will be announced on Tuesday's show.

I also know that preliminary TV ratings put the audience at a little more than 26 million viewers. At around 9:30 p.m., when Lakisha Jones was told she was safe, that number had swelled to 30 million. And Ben Stiller was still singing "Reminiscing."

As for rocker week, which former contestant will I miss the most? Gina Glocksen, of course.

Posted by Leigh Grogan at 01:54 PM | Comments

Charity abounds on 'Idol'

Fox/Frank Micelotta

Covering "American Idol" for the past 15 weeks has had "E" written all over it: entertaining, exacerbating, exciting, exhausting. And now, add emotional to the list.

Wednesday night's "Idol Gives Back" two-hour finale had results all right, but of the charitable kind. That even extended to the Top 6 contestants who, you may have heard by now, were kept safe for another week.

(Dressed in white, mostly jackets and pants - Chris Richardson wore a hoodie - the contestants all had an almost angelic look about them. Either that or they're planning a huge revival of "Saturday Night Fever.")

Throughout the show, various contestants were told they were safe, until we were left with two - Jordin Sparks and Chris - with about 10 minutes to go. (There was some speculation earlier Wednesday among some "AI" bloggers that all contestants would be given a temporary pass. I wondered about that, but had already received notice of a conference call with whomever would be the eliminated contestant, so I discounted it. I even went ahead with a note on page E1 of today's Scene, asking folks to check back here for that interview.)

Anyway, as host Ryan Seacrest put it in the end: "How could we let anybody go on charity night?"

Indeed.

I'm not sure when the "Idol" powers that be made this call. It might have been in the works from the beginning; it might have been made Wednesday after more than 70 million votes were cast. A world record.

No matter - the whole show still had "American Idol" stamped all over it. And, whether you're a fan or find it all a bit much, you can't argue with the fact that the show's producers, creators, etc., know exactly what they're doing.

They're very, very smart people. After all, they stumped me!

Wednesday's show, unlike a lot of fundraising programs, was a clever combination of promoting the cause (helping impoverished children and families in Africa and the U.S.) and offering entertainment. At one point, I lost count of all the celebrities who donated either their musical skills, comedic skills or just their faces to urge viewers to donate.

Even last week's ousted contestant, Sanjaya Malakar, was in the audience, smiling and applauding next to his sullen sister, who looked like she was about to go in for a root canal.

In no particular order, here's some of what happened on this amazing show:

* Everyone got gussied up again, including the three judges. Simon Cowell wore a jacket - dude cleans up nicely when he wants to. Paula Abdul showed a little - make that a lot - more cleavage than I thought necessary. Randy Jackson was in perfect "Dawg" attire.

* Ellen Degeneres, no novice when it comes to hosting, handled the big musical acts over at the Walt Disney Concert Hall. That's where we saw Earth, Wind & Fire, Il Divo (whose rendition of "Somewhere" brought out copious Kleenex in my house), Rascal Flats, Josh Groban (singing "You Raise Me Up" with the African Children's Choir - again, more tears), and Season 1 winner Kelly Clarkson (singing "Up to the Mountain"). She was accompanied by where-in-the-world-has-he-been guitarist Jeff Beck and, finally, the great Annie Lennox with "Bridge Over Troubled Water," which also featured footage of her trip to Africa.

* Ellen personally donated $100,000 and challenged the "rich people who I watch the show with" to match her pledge. She brought just the right mix of humor and encouragement. For example:

"I had breakfast with Sanjaya this morning and he offered two pieces of advice: 'Deep condition once a week' and 'donate.' "

* Ford is making it possible to download some of the performances from iTunes, including my favorite of the evening, Season 4 winner Carrie Underwood's "I'll Stand By You." Carrie had also traveled to Africa, and her performance and that of her three-piece band, was amazing. She clearly was touched by the kids and their plight.

* Celebrities who couldn't sing instead made personal pitches for aid. We saw Dr. Phil, David Schwimmer, Eric McCormack, Teri Hatcher, Madonna and Forest Whitaker. Somehow, the show assembled 36 celebs, including NBA stars LeBron James and Shaquille O'Neal, and Academy Award winners Gwyneth Paltrow and Helen Mirren, for a montage of "Stayin' Alive," which the Top 6 contestants watched as part of their weekly Ford commercial stint.

* Actor Ben Stiller was remotely located in what appeared to be his den. He intitially had some issues with his "hair" (too many fly-aways), got that corrected and then vowed to "sing" the Little River Band's "Reminiscing" until the show raised $200 billion! What a team player.

* The biggest/weirdest moment - depending on how you look at it - was the much-ballyhooed duet between two of the world's best entertainers. It proved to be Celine "Don't-sing-her-songs" Dion and a computer-generated Elvis. I
speculated that something like this would happen (see my earlier posting below) and, while it was ambitious, I thought it was a little creepy.

* Footage of Simon and Ryan's multiple visits to orphaned children and AIDs patients in Africa definitely was the most inspirational and, at times, almost hard to watch. Say what you want about Simon - and we have - but the man's heart is in the right place.

* Comedian Jack Black did his wacky part. Ryan had asked for a volunteer to cough up $50 for a chance to come up on stage and introduce the next act. Jack (natch) won and basically took over, deciding this was his opportunity to audition. His rendition of "Kiss From a Rose" brought tears to one audience member - the guy sitting next to him holding a pink rose. Jack challenged the three judges, who called his performance "crappy," though Simon admitted he did sing "better than Sanjaya." Even the song's original singer, Seal, was right there to disagree, saying it was the best rendition he had heard. "You worked it out," he shouted to Jack, who stumbled and thought he was auditioning for "America's Next Top Model."

* The show ended with U2's Bono meeting with the Top 6 contestants. He told them that people say this generation can't put an end to "brutal, stupid poverty."

"But there are soccer moms, punk rockers, church people - even Irish rock stars on 'American Idol' - who can make a difference.

"Music whispers in your ear, and the impossible is possible," Bono said. "Remember the lives you are transforming. There's not a person who can't save a life."

Then it was time for Melinda Doolittle, Blake Lewis, Phil Stacey, Lakisha Jones, Chris and Jordin to perform "American Prayer" (shown above ) to end the evening.

I watched both the East Coast and West Coast feeds, which resulted in the need for multiple Kleenex. As of 7 p.m. PDT, when the folks in New York and Florida were done, almost $30 million already was raised.

I hope to have an updated figure in this space sometime today, as well as the musical genre for next week's competition.

Speaking of next week, the 70 million votes cast this week will be added to the contestants' votes after performing next Tuesday. The bottom two will be eliminated, which gets us back on track for the "American Idol" finale on May 23.

The biggest question? Is Stiller still "Reminiscing?"

Posted by Leigh Grogan at 08:36 AM | Comments

April 25, 2007

Singing for a cause

Fox/Frank Micelotta

OK, so either you were wiping tears from your eyes - or rolling them - during Tuesday's first night of "Idol Gives Back." Cynics, you know who you are.

I happened to fall into the first category. The songs that the Top 6 sang were very moving, as were the tapes of the three judges and host Ryan Seacrest visiting impoverished areas of Africa and right here in the U.S.A. The images of starving, sick kids, the homeless, the helpless. It was wrenching and, I think, very believeable.

Ryan opened the show by saying it would be the same three judges, the same six contestants, but that the calls would not only save the performers, they would save lives.

As you already know, the "Idol Gives Back" effort is to raise money to help people who can't help themselves. Right off the bat, Ryan announced that News Corporation (which owns Fox, which broadcasts "American Idol") would donate 10 cents for the first 50 million calls made.

Ford, Coca-Cola and AT&T are also sponsors.

Oh, and yes, the Top 6 contestants did perform their choice of songs that they think are inspiring, and one of them will go home tonight. And, if you think 38 million votes last week was a boatload, I can't even fathom how many were cast Tuesday night.

That said, here are the high notes - and only one low note - from Tuesday's performances:

* Chris Richardson: He sang Eric Clapton's "Change the World." Accompanied by a guitarist, Chris (shown above) said he picked the song because it says what the show is all about. "If you can imagine what one person could do to change things, imagine what millions could do."

Randy Jackson: "You know where I really love the show. This time of the season because it's the first time, dawg, that I think you're in it to win it."

Paula Abdul: "You did fantastic. Great song choice. Well done. It's exciting to see your journey from where you were to where you are now."

Simon Cowell: "It feels like the competition starts properly tonight. This reminds me of the first time we saw you. It was a good vocal, more soul, more sexy. You did very well."

On a fashion note: Chris wore a coat and tie (something was amiss with it, though) and the requisite sneakers. Even Simon gussied up for the occasion, wearing an open-collared, buttons-opened dress shirt. Ryan quipped at one point that he had "lost a button."

* Melinda Doolittle: She sang Faith Hill's "There Will Come a Day." She said the song speaks to the problems in our country and the world today. "It talks about a hope for a better tomorrow, and that's what tonight is all about."

Randy: "Every week, you're our resident pro. You've got it all together. Every performance is great. You have arrived. Melinda is home."

Paula: "It must feel great week after week, getting praised and loved. There's no one like you. You're magical."

Simon: "What I loved is it wasn't a copycat performance. You took a song and made me believe you recorded it originally. That was a vocal master class."

On a surprise note: Once again, Melinda obeyed Simon's order not to look surprised when he compliments her.

* Blake Lewis: He sang John Lennon's "Imagine." He said he was very honored to sing this particular song. "It's about coming together as one in an ideal world."

Randy: "Great choice of song. On the performance side, it was just OK for me. I'm just keeping it real."

Paula: "How beautiful and simple that song is. This is the first real emotional performance I've seen tonight. I really enjoyed it."

Simon: "That's a tricky one. You know you've chosen one of the biggest songs of all time. You can't belt it out. It felt sincere, but it didn't go anywhere. However, the most important part is that you sang it with sincerity, and that was good."

On a personal note: Blake said the biggest sacrifice being on "American Idol" was "missing my friends and family from home."

* Lakisha Jones: She sang Fantasia Barrino's "I Believe." She said the song inspired her. "If we unite together, we can make a difference to a lot of people who are struggling and suffering. It's time to make a change."

Randy: "There were some pitch problems at the beginning. It wasn't your best performance. It's hard to sing that song after Fantasia. I only hear her singing that."

Paula: "You're a powerhouse of a vocalist. But we've talked about singing Celine (Dion), Whitney (Houston) and Chaka (Kahn). Fantasia hasn't been around a long time, but she's so unique."

Simon: "What Paula is trying to say is, she preferred the Fantasia version. It was very emotional. But the issue again is with the shouting."

On a critical note: If not for Sanjaya Malakar, Lakisha might have gotten the boot last week for singing Carrie Underwood's "Jesus Take the Wheel." She survived, though, only to come back this week - almost defiant - and take on Fantasia. It's almost like she wants to go home.

* Phil Stacey: He sang Garth Brooks' "The Change." He said the song was recorded after the Oklahoma City bombings. "It made a profound impact on my life. All the amazing heroism. We've got the chance to be heroes if we take advantage of this amazing opportunity."

Randy: "You know what I'm happy about? Since last week, you did your thing. You're back again with a nice vocal on a very great song. Two weeks in a row. You've found your comfort zone."

Paula: "It was fantastic. Your best."

Simon: "I really like you, Phil. I'm glad you had a good week. You've got a spring in your step. You're confident. Country suits your voice. If you can connect with the two elements (song choice and vocals), you could do well because people like you."

On another fashion note: I liked Phil in his more dressed-up persona - even without a hat.

* Jordin Sparks: She sang "You'll Never Walk Alone." The song was written by Richard Rodgers and Oscar Hammerstein for their 1945 musical, "Carousel." Jordin said the song has a great message of hope. "With all that's going on in the world and so much going on in our country, it has a comforting message."

Randy: "You know something? It's so true. That was one of the best vocals by anyone on this show in any season - and from someone who is only 17!"

Paula: "You picked an amazing song. Very haunting. Only someone with great vocals could do it. And you look lovely."

Simon: "I thought you were fantastic. That song is more than 60 years old, but you could have a hit record with that."

On another personal note: I can remember singing this song (certainly not like Jordin) in church more than 30 years ago, so it's definitely got staying power.

And, just in case you were anywhere but in front of the TV Tuesday night, the show was interspersed with footage of Simon and Ryan visiting children and adults in Africa, with Simon almost breaking down numerous times. Randy also visited his home state of Louisiana to meet folks still dealing with the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina. Paula hooked up with Ryan to meet kids in need.

But it was Simon's visit to a place called Harold's Pantry in L.A., a few blocks from his own home, that was the clincher. There he saw volunteers filling boxes with food for those in need.

"I had no idea that places like this exist," Simon said. "Volunteers who are mothers and daughters."

He even found a couple of women who he went up to and said, "I never meet nice people. Give me a hug."

I believe "American Idol" accomplished what it set out to do and that's to raise money. We'll find out tonight just how much.

As for the predictions on who's going home? DialIdol.com has Jordin totally safe, with (in order) Phil, Lakisha, Blake, Melinda and Chris in peril. As for me, I think Lakisha will be eliminated. Two risky performances in a row? That's one too many. And Simon is right about the shouting. It hurt my ears.

Tonight's two-hour results show (at 8 on Channel 40) will feature beaucoup stars. If you've been paying attention, Ryan announced last week that there would be a duet on tonight's show that "you'll have to see to believe."

I got it from a very reliable "Idol" confidante that the duo is Celine Dion and, believe it or not, Elvis!

Posted by Leigh Grogan at 10:40 AM | Comments

April 24, 2007

Voicing concern

"Idol" host Ryan Seacrest and judge Simon Cowell meet with schoolchildren in Africa leading up to the "Idol Gives Back" campaign.
Fox

Well, they've been promoting it all of Season 6. That would be the big two-night "Idol Gives Back" special to raise awareness and funds for kids in need in both Africa and right here in the United States.

It kicks off at 8 p.m. Tuesday (on Channel 40), with the competition show and the Top 6 contestants singing "life anthems." (For more on the song possibilities, check out Bee pop music critic Chris Macias' blog, BeatNonStop.)

Then, on Wednesday, it's a two-hour results show - also starting at 8 p.m. - that requires two venues because of all the celebs and VIPs who want to sing, act out, act up, juggle (just kidding), take up space, get their faces on TV or promote something other than the good cause. There's even a guest host, Ellen Degeneres. What are they planning to do with Ryan? Give him the night off?

Oh, and by the way, one more "American Idol" contestant will be tossed. Phil Stacey, who is the pick at Votefortheworst.com ("We love you even if you can't be exposed to direct sunlight"), could surprise everyone by not leaving, just like during country music week. Song choice will be huge.

They're touting "Gives Back" as the biggest moment in "Idol" history. But I'm just waiting to see if judge Simon Cowell wears something other than a T-shirt. And, somehow, it's just not going to be the same without Sanjaya Malakar, who continues to pound the press pavement from coast to coast. Interestingly, he's not been asked to actually perform at all of his appearances. His hair, of course, is still generating the most interest.

Did you catch his appearance on David Letterman's “Late Show" on Monday night? No, he didn't sing, but he did get to read the evening's Top 10 list, which was “Things I Learned From 'American Idol.' "

I jotted down some of my favorites, in no particular order:

* The camera adds 10 pounds to your mohawk.
* Work hard and make sacrifices, you can finish in seventh place.
* Voting for yourself 100 times an hour causes some wicked carpal tunnel.
* America loves performers with bad hair – right, Dave?
* Nothing!

And, this just in: The show continues to dominate the Nielsens. What jumps out to me is that last week's results show topped the competition show. Did viewers all have a feeling about Sanjaya?:

1. “American Idol” (Wednesday), 28.93 million viewers.
2. “American Idol” (Tuesday), 26.55 million viewers.

Posted by Leigh Grogan at 03:55 PM | Comments

April 23, 2007

Sanjaya goes East Coast

Associated Press/Stephen J. Boitano

Sanjaya Malakar has made his way across the country for numerous post-"Idol" appearances. I caught him this morning on "Live With Regis and Kelly" (Bryant Gumbel was the guest co-host). Sanjaya performed what I thought was his best song in the competition - his rendition of "Besame Mucho," which he did during Latin week.

And, lo and behold, Sanjaya had a new coif, one that I hadn’t seen before. He was sporting a sort of pulled-back look, pouffy in the back, with what looked like multicolored barrettes. Another schtick: While he sang (and mugged longingly into the camera), the cameras went back and forth from him to a man dressed up like the little girl who cried in the “Idol” audience. Good stuff!

During a commercial break, Kelly Ripa’s stylist quickly converted her hair into a matching Sanjaya ’do. It looked just as cute on her. In fact, Kelly joked that Sanjaya had stolen some of his “Idol” hairstyles from her.

Sanjaya reiterated what he told some of us "Idol" reporters last week: That he wants to experience the entire entertainment industry, from singing to modeling to acting.

Kelly asked him if his feelings had been hurt by what the three judges said to him on the show.

"I tried to be positive," Sanjaya said. "They (the judges) are brutal sometimes, but I tried to learn from it. You can't let the negativity sit in your soul."

Meanwhile, day-to-day life apparently has changed dramatically for the ousted Sanjaya. Obviously, he can't just walk down the street; fans want hugs and autographs. I'm not sure this phenomenon is happening for Haley Scarnato, who was eliminated the week before Sanjaya. Just sayin'.

Heck, Sanjaya even got to attend the White House Correspondents' Association Dinner in Washington, D.C., (pictured above) on Saturday as a guest of People magazine. He looks handsome in his suit.

"It was interesting," Sanjaya said. "I met the governor of New York (Eliot Spitzer), who told me he votes on the show."

Sanjaya is headed back home to Federal Way, Wash. on Tuesday, just as the Top 6 "Idol" finalists gear up for the ginormous "Idol Gives Back" two-night extravaganza. More on that to come.

Posted by Leigh Grogan at 02:46 PM | Comments

April 20, 2007

Some 'Idol' thoughts

What will we do without Sanjaya?

Life goes on. And so will all you "Idol" fans. But, just in case you feel the need to show your affection for the most recently eliminated contestant, there are T-shirts from Busted Tees (shown left) that fit the saddened mood, well, to a "tee." Check it out.

Meanwhile, I caught "American Idol Extra" on Reality Remix Thursday night. It's still kind of amazing to see the contestants coming down the steps of the stage just as the show is ending. Here's a snippet of what a couple of the surviving (Top 6) had to say:

* Blake Lewis: "Wednesdays - Ugh!"
* Melinda Doolittle: "Bye, baby boy."

And speaking of Sanjaya, he was the last to exit, saying, "Hello, er, rather goodbye" to the waiting cameras. In an interview in the Remix studio, I was kind of surprised at how small Sanjaya is and, interestingly, it was his cousin in the audience Wednesday instead of his parents. It was the one week his mom wasn't on hand. (She needed a break.) But she and his sister were about to catch a red-eye to L.A. to be with him.

Sanjaya did say that his elimination was no big shocker to him. "When I was next to Blake and Lakisha (Jones), I knew I was going home."

Also on "Remix," "Idol" producer Nigel Lythgoe said he knew late Tuesday night who was going home. He admitted he was kind of shocked at the bottom three. And of Sanjaya's exit, he said, "It was a little sad."

And this from judge Simon Cowell: "It was getting to a point where, when we get to the Top 3 or Top 4, we would have a problem (if Sanjaya was still in). But, in a strange way, we miss him."

The remaining six contestants were asked to tell us who they would really love to sing with. Interestingly, none of them picked any of the previous mentors. Here we go:

* Melinda: Stevie Wonder
* Blake: Prince
* Lakisha: Whitney Houston
* Chris Richardson: Jason Mraz
* Jordin Sparks: Pat Benatar
* Phil Stacey: Sting

In more "Idol" news:

* Ousted contestant, rocker Gina Glocksen, finally got her big hometown reception in Naperville, Ill. "I was judged by 33 million people - and Simon Cowell!" she shouted to the thousands who showed up for "Gina Glocksen Day."

* Season 5 country crooner Bucky Covington got plenty of face time on the show this season to tout his new, self-named album. I even caught a clip of his music video. Same fun-loving Bucky. I've heard the CD is getting mixed reviews, but I thought his voice certainly sounded stronger than last year.

* Now that Sanjaya is no longer on the show, Votefortheworst.com has anointed Phil as the site's new vote-getter.

* One final note, just in from Fox: You all have to know by now that the big "Idol Gives Back" week starts with Tuesday night's show (at 8 p.m. on Channel 40). Instead of a musical mentor, the Top 6 finalists will sing songs that can be considered “life anthems.” After the show, viewers can vote for their favorite contestants via toll-free numbers and text messages, as usual. On this special night, however, for every vote cast, sponsors will donate money to the charity.

Posted by Leigh Grogan at 12:16 PM | Comments

April 19, 2007

Chatting with Sanjaya

So much has been made about Sanjaya Malakar's youthfulness. He's 17, for anyone just catching up with "American Idol." But, compared to 24-year-old Haley Scarnato's exit interview last week, Sanjaya seems all grown-up.

Yes, he's quite soft-spoken, but he handled a conference call today with "Idol" reporters with a heck of a lot of poise. So, for those of you who are fans, don't worry - he'll be just fine.

And yes, he's heard about everything everyone has been saying about him, including the spoofing, the jokes (some funny, some hurtful), Howard Stern, and Votefortheworst.com. He's read the blogs about him, which generally is discouraged for the contestants' sanity.

He'll be heading back to Federal Way, Wash., next week - after a blitz of interviews. Here's what he had to say about his "Idol" experience:

Q: Were you surprised by all the fans you've earned during your stint on "Idol?" And did you think you could win it all?

A: It's crazy. I knew the show was big. I just didn't realize how much of an impact it has. However, I really was more focused on the learning aspect of the show. I grew throughout the competition, and I found myself through that.

Q: Did you see the end coming?

A: When I watched (the tape of) Tuesday's show, I kind of had a feeling. I was in the dumps on Wednesday.

Q: Did the judges' criticism, especially from Simon Cowell, get to you?

A: I try to make everything into a positive and learn from it. It's like water rolling off a duck's back. From the beginning, I don't think I fulfilled my potential, and Simon was disappointed. He's an amazing person. What he does is awesome. Yes, he's very opinionated, but I learned more from him than anyone else on the show.

Q: Much has been made about your many hairstyles. Did you have a lot of say in how you looked each week? And which was your favorite?

A: With my hair, I always had an idea what I wanted. My stylist worked with me and also with my clothes. It's a lot about my personality and putting it out there. The hairstyle ideas were mainly mine, but I had help. My favorite hairstyle was during Latin week, when I sang "Besame Mucho."

Q: You're only 17. What about high school?

A: I got my GED as a sophomore, so this is like my junior and senior years combined. I had a little trouble in high school. I didn't do my homework, which is a horrible habit. But I do want to go to college and finish my education. My dream would be to go to the Berklee School of Music.

Q: Did you ever think you were in over your head?

A: The only time I really felt like that was Hollywood Week. It was completely intense. Kind of scary.

Q: How did what you read online or what people were saying impact you? Did you hear about being mentioned on a presidential debate?

A: When "Saturday Night Live" did that skit on me and said, "I don't know if he's scared or happy," I cracked up. I love to poke fun at myself. It's important to be able to make fun of yourself. As for the debate, that's really interesting. That a 17-year-old Seattle boy could impact a presidential debate.

Q: What was that moment like when you were eliminated and got a big hug from Lakisha (Jones)?

A: A lot of emotion came out because I'm being torn away from my family. She said goodbye and good luck - everyone's been so supportive. We all had the same amount of pressure. We all wanted to win.

Q: So, what's next?

A: I go home next week. I think I'm gonna rest and try to get back into as normal a life as I can. Then, I'll be back for the finale and the tour.

Q: Being so young, how will you handle decisions about your future?

A: I have a lot of support. My mother is an amazingly smart woman, and I have awesome support from Fox. My main thing, when I choose endorsements, is to pick something I feel strongly about. It's not about the money. It's just paper. It's about having an image and putting your true self out there. The money will come.

Q: Are you ready to hire a bodyguard?

A: I'm ready to hire a bodyguard. I'm looking into that right now.

Posted by Leigh Grogan at 01:29 PM | Comments

April 18, 2007

So long, Sanjaya

Fox/Frank Micelotta

Well, I was never really sure, never really certain this would be the week Sanjaya Malakar (shown above), master of disguise, would be eliminated from Season 6.

But, it happened tonight.

With a record-setting 38 million votes cast for a Top 7 elimination round, Sanjaya, 17, of Federal Way, Wash., is right about now probably packing his flat iron, his hot rollers, his mousse and his memories.

And guess what? When I saw him tear up at the announcement, I told my "Idol"-watching buddies, "Hey, I think I'm gonna miss this guy." You, too? Shoot me an e-mail.

And, stay glued to this space, where I'll be posting a Q&A with Sanjaya on Thursday.

Heck, even my 14-year-old son, who doesn't even watch the show, lamented, "That's the only person I knew on the show!"

Sanjaya used every trick in the book to stick around. He smiled when the three judges chastised him, he changed his look from week to week, and I have to admit this, he was getting somewhat better vocally - not enough to win, certainly. But his rendition of Bonnie Raitt's "Something To Talk About" on Tuesday night just didn't give fans - even the teeny-boppers - something to vote for.

Surprisingly, he was joined in the bottom three by Blake Lewis, who I thought did a nice job Tuesday. Yes, country music is not necessarily his strongest genre, but I thought Chris Richardson would be there. And, not surprisingly, Lakisha Jones filled out the trio. She seemed stunned. But come on, taking on Carrie Underwood's "Jesus Take the Wheel?" Too soon. Waaay too soon.

One moment will be burned in my "Idol" analogs for a long, long time. At the very onset of the show, host Ryan Seacrest mentioned an incident that happened on Tuesday night's show that caused quite a bit of controversy and confusion. The outcry was over judge Simon Cowell seemingly rolling his eyes as contestant (and Virginia native) Chris made a closing remark about the tragedy at Virginia Tech. Ryan allowed Simon to clear the air. Here's what he had to say:

"I usually don't comment on a press story, but there was a heated debate between myself and Chris about him singing through his nose. After the exchange, Chris mentioned the people in Virginia. I need to set the record straight. I didn't hear what Chris was saying. The implication was that I was disrespecting the victims. Now, I might not be the nicest person in the world, but I would never do something like that. I was talking to Paula (Abdul) about Chris' comments on intentionally singing in a nasal voice."

Ryan retorted that there's "always another show happening at this table every week."

Anyway, in my opinion: Yes, he might be a cuss sometimes, but even Simon Cowell could never be that cruel.

Moving on: The hourlong results show was filled with, uh, filler, including:

* Another Ryan on-the-street Q&A with random "Idol" fans. He always seems to find some weirdo oddball who rambles aimlessly. One woman said she didn't think the guys had it this year. Another was "worried about Lakisha."

* The Top 7 singing Sugarland's "I'm All Right." It was just all right. I mean, together, they still sound like a really good high school musical ensemble.

* A brief glimpse of Season 5's Bucky Covington in the audience. His CD came out this week but, hey, no shout-out from Ryan.

* Ryan asking the burning question: What do the Top 7 listen to in their spare time?

Answers: Melinda Doolittle: "Fred Hammond. I need a Jesus song during the day."

Blake: "The new Incubus album."

Jordin Sparks: "Fergie. I like her new single, 'Glamorous.' "

Phil Stacey: "Willie Nelson."

Chris: "Maroon 5, Jason Mraz. My favorite is Peter Noone (Herman's Hermits and a British Invasion mentor).

Lakisha: "Yolanda Adams."

Most of this was shot as the contestants were either eating (out of styrofoam boxes) or having their hair and makeup done.

* The weekly Ford commercial, which was some sort of heist thing with the contestants singing "I Ran" and Sanjaya looking amazingly like actor Steven Segal.

* A tease to "Idol Gives Back," which continues to grow and grow - and grow. The list of corporations and celebrities participating is mindboggling. Underwood, Gwen Stefani, Pink, Earth, Wind & Fire, Kelly Clarkson, Josh Groban, and on and on.

Ryan mentioned there would be a "duet you'll have to see to believe." The performers weren't revealed, but on a subsequent Coke commercial, Celine Dion's name came up.

* And a filler/promotional moment that I could have done without. The Top 7 take a ride over to DreamWorks, meet CEO/movie honcho Jeffrey Katzenberg, take turns dubbing some of the characters' voices for the new movie "Shrek the Third," meet Antonio Banderas (voice of Puss in Boots), see the movie, gloat over the movie, and - at last! - go back to their "Idol" chores.

But then, as if it couldn't get more pluggish, Antonio is in the audience, with wife Melanie ("I haven't made a movie in years") Griffith, daughter Stella and Jeffrey who, mercifully, introduces this week's musical mentor, Martina McBride.

Martina's performance seemed choreographed for such a difficult week. We knew she was going to sing her new single, "Anyway," but who knew the words would take on such meaning:

"God is great, but sometimes life ain't good
And when I pray, it doesn't always turn out like I think it should
But I do it anyway, I do it anyway."

Her daughter, Emma, joins her on the stage and pretty much takes over, complimenting her mom's album, the Top 7 contestants, and pulling a Paula-esque, "Everybody is great!"

Martina gets a word in, saying she couldn't make the decision on who goes home. "America makes that decision. And we'll find out after the break." Hmmm... very Ryan-esque.

Speaking of which: Much to the contestants' angst/delight, Ryan had broken them into groups - the top three and the bottom three but, as with every season, we don't know which is which. I could guess, though. Did you?

Group 1: Phil, Jordin and Chris.
Group 2: Sanjaya, Lakisha and Blake

Melinda is the contestant first declared safe, and then she's put in that ridiculously awkward position of picking which of the two groups is worst/best. My girl Melinda folds up and sits cross-legged in the center of the stage. No comment.

"That is fair and fitting," Ryan says. "Slide to your left. This group (Phil, Jordin and Chris) are safe."

Then, the judges weighed in:

Randy: "Dawg, I think it's crazy that Blake's up there!"

Paula: "Blake's grandmother is here, and I hope she's not getting too upset. I understand why two of you are up there."

Simon: "I'm beginning to sense something here."

As usual, because the clock is ticking, Ryan pulls out the safety net for my boy Blake, who appears genuinely grateful.

And now, it's between Sanjaya and Lakisha - and it's quick and painless: "Sanjaya goes home tonight."

He says: "It's been an amazing experience."

Ryan says: "We won't soon forget you."

Note to you: Here's where I hope you "Idol" fans were paying close attention to Sanjaya's farewell version of "Something To Talk About." Did you catch him changing the lyrics to "Let's give 'em something to talk about, other than hair?" Loved it. Loved it. Loved it. He should do that on the tour this summer.

Posted by Leigh Grogan at 11:14 PM | Comments

Country in (some) chaos

Fox/Frank Micelotta

Well, what started off as a hopeful night of country-music performances turned into a mixed bag of "what the heck?" on Tuesday's "American Idol."

I was stunned, I mean stunned, with Phil Stacey's opening song and then even more impressed with Jordin Sparks (shown above). I predicted Phil would be taking his chrome dome home tonight, but all bets are off there. (More on the predictions later.)

The country genre stumped at least three of the Top 7 contestants, with Sanjaya Malakar the most ludicrous - in both song choice and hair accessory, which was a picnic-table-sized bandana holding back an abundance of hot-rollered curls.

Could this finally be it for him? Well, it's up to the nation's 13-year-olds in my opinion.

Country superstar Martina McBride was this week's musical mentor, and I thought she did a great job. Constructive criticism, good advice. After all, you know what you're doing if you've sold $16 million in CDs and hauled in 23 music awards.

She gave her thoughts on what it means to actually perform a country music song:

"It's all about storytelling. The best songs sound like conversations. Connect with the lyrics and the great melodies, and don't worry about it being country music. I know it's not Simon's (Cowell) favorite genre, but maybe tonight he'll change his mind."

Sorry, Martina. That probably didn't happen.

But let's keep things moving. Here are the high - and low - notes from Tuesday night's competition:

* Phil Stacey: He sang Keith Urban's "Where the Blacktop Ends." Yeehah! What an impressive turnaround from, well, since the season started. Phil, who I figured would butcher this genre, got the competition off to an impressive start. Martina felt he was a little stiff and precise at the get-go, but "he threw in this great, soulful lick toward the end. I've loved him since the beginning."

Randy Jackson: "What's interesting, dude, is from a producer's standpoint, you have a career in country music. Who knew? That was really good."

Paula Abdul: "You sounded good from the beginning. It's a genre you feel most comfortable in."

Simon: "It's only taken 10 weeks. I agree. It's the only time I've heard you - in a long, long time - choose a good song. The style of music suited you. And we actually saw some personality. I don't know if it was enough to save you."

Note to Simon: I think you and Phil are going to be best buds for at least another week.

* Jordin Sparks: She sang "Broken Wing," always a risky thing to do in front of the performer who performed it. Even Jordin admitted she was "scared, but I hope I can make her (Martina) proud." Martina was indeed impressed. "That was awesome. I want her to plant her feet strong. It's not about moving. (The song's) so strong, it's about your expression."

Randy: "That was probably one of the most difficult songs to sing because of the way the original was sung. But, and I keep saying this, at 17, wow! That was the bomb!"

Paula: "You look gorgeous (natch). You did a fantastic job. I love you. You just stood there, built the song and told a story."

Simon: "This is the first time since we've met where I actually believe, based on your performance, you could win 'American Idol.' "

Note to Jordin: How amazing is it that you get nervous after performing instead of beforehand?

* Sanjaya Malakar: He sang Bonnie Raitt's "Something To Talk About," saying he hoped he could do Bonnie justice. Uh-huh. "I picked this song because I give people something to talk about, and it's fun to say that." Martina told him it was a good song choice. "He has typically been singing in this soft voice, but I told him he needed a stronger voice, more confident. If he projects more, I think he'll have a great time."

Randy: "You know the Dawg keeps it real. It was really karaoke. Vocally not good at all. It was just bland and boring for me. I mean, what are we doing up here, Paula?"

Paula: "We're watching somebody who loves adversity. You thrive on it. You're a lovable guy."

Simon: "It was utterly horrendous. Seriously, if I'm being honest, it was as bad as anything we see at the beginning of 'American Idol' (i.e., the auditions)."

Note to viewers: If you missed the show, the following exchange between Simon, Sanjaya and host Ryan Seacrest got down and dirty. But help me, guys, are they just funning with each other? It went something like this:

Ryan: "Even if it wasn't that good, you've never really liked this guy" (meaning Sanjaya).

Simon: "Who rattled your cage? It was funny for a while. But we're supposed to be finding the next 'American Idol.' It was hideous and a ridiculous choice of song."

Ryan: "But you never liked him."

Simon: "I liked him last week, big mouth. Get the tape."

Randy (chiming in): "I liked the scarf on the hair."

Sanjaya: Says nothing. Just smiles. He's staying.

Nice going, Simon.

* Lakisha Jones: She sang "Jesus Take the Wheel" by Season 4 winner Carrie Underwood. In my opinion, this was an even bigger risk than Jordin singing a Martina song. It's so, well, very, very Carrie. When asked why she picked it, Lakisha said it was because of all she'd been through in her life, "being a single parent." Martina said she wisely chose a song she relates to. "She definitely connected to a particular lyric. I love her voice, it's a gift."

Randy: "Lakisha, Lakisha, Lakisha. For me, this had some pitch problems in the beginning. It's not my favorite vocal performance. I'm not sure it was in your wheelhouse (huh?). You're more of a gospel girl."

Paula: "I have to agree with Randy. The first time you may have heard it differently but, with the swell of the band, it was like you were shouting. But, you're still brilliant. So what?"

Simon: "It's like eating a hamburger for breakfast. It doesn't go together. You and the song don't go well together. Halfway through, you gave it the 'Lakisha treatment.' You blew us away with the Jennifer Holiday song eight or nine weeks ago. That's when you chose the right song."

Fashion note to "Idol" stylists: Yes, you guys picked a more flattering dress for Lakisha this week, but what the hey was up with those gold lame boots? Instead of her dress being a distraction, now it's her feet. Geez!

* Chris Richardson: He sang "Mayberry" by Rascal Flats. Now, I know all about the town because I'm a huge "Andy Griffith" fan, but the song threw me - and Martina, too." "I questioned that choice of song," she said. "But his voice fits the genre. He could sing pop or country - he's very versatile."

Randy: "The funny thing about this music, doing country, is it was absolutely the correct song. But it was a little nasally. I had no sense of connection. I felt lost during the song. No emotion."

Paula: "He sang OK. I kind of understand. But the joy and the love on the stage didn't come through. He knows what I'm talking about."

Simon: "The audience and me are hearing different things (tonight). What I heard was a nondescript, nasally, tinny vocal. It was completely and utterly insignificant - the whole thing. No impact on me at all."

Vocal note (and another Simon/Ryan exchange):
Ryan: "He hears different things because his head is so big."

Chris: "Nasally is a form of singing."

Simon: "So, it's intentional."

* Melinda Doolittle: She sang "Trouble is a Woman" by Julie Reeves. Never heard of it. Martina said she'd never heard it before, either. "But, it didn't matter. I couldn't take my eyes off her. I was completely glued to her. Wow, amazing. It's the perfect song choice for her."

Randy: "All I can say is it was another solid performance for our resident pro. Miss Melinda Doolittle, fantastic!"

Paula: "You picked the right song, you performed your heart out like there's no tomorrow."

Simon: "I'm about to compliment you, so I'm going to ask you to not look surprised. It was fantastic. It was a good choice of song. It was a little bit of Tina Turner going on, with the attitude going back to your Southern thing."

Note to Melinda: Kudos for following instructions and not looking surprised when Simon passed out praise. I don't think I could have taken Round 3 between Simon and Ryan.

* Blake Lewis: He sang "When the Stars Go Blue" by Tim McGraw. "This is definitely a big departure for me," Blake said. Martina told him she had recently spoken with Tim, who was hoping someone on "Idol" would "sing my song." She added she hoped Blake would relax on the show because he was a little nervous with her. "It's nice to hear him sing. He has an interesting style, with the falsetto. He just needs to zone in on the lyrics."

Randy: "What I love about you is you picked the right song. The arrangement suited you. And I love that you know who you are."

Paula: "You kind of have the whole package. Your 'isms.' It's always fun to watch you. It was a great song."

Simon: "It wasn't a jumping-out-of-my-seat performance. It was OK. I agree with Randy, it was wise not to go down a route that doesn't suit you. It was a tricky week for you guys (and girls) because it's been very trying."

Note from me: Props to Ryan, Chris R. (who is from Virginia) and Simon for mentioning the tragedy at Virginia Tech. Ryan spoke of it right at the beginning of the show, saying, "At this difficult time, our thoughts and prayers are with you." Chris mentioned it before leaving the stage, and Simon made reference to it in his comments about the week being difficult. I grew up about an hour or so from the campus, and it was nice to have a show I've been so connected to take a moment to acknowledge the tragedy.

And now, for the predictions:

Over at DialIdol.com, they've got Phil being the only truly safe contestant this week. Then, in order of who might go home, it's Jordin, Chris, Melinda, Lakisha, Blake and Sanjaya.

OK, I never dreamed Phil would do as well as he did with country music. I agree with Randy. He could be the next Bucky Covington - with less hair. So, I'm putting Sanjaya, Lakisha and Chris in the bottom three. Chris gets the safety net; Sanjaya gets a plane ticket back to Federal Way, Wash.

Tonight's results show is at 9 on Channel 40. Don't surprise me!

Posted by Leigh Grogan at 10:57 AM | Comments

April 17, 2007

Break out the cowboy boots

Fox/Ray Mickshaw

The remaining seven "American Idol" contestants hooked up with country crooner Martina McBride (shown above) in preparation for tonight's country music competition.

And I have absolutely no clue what to expect. Do you?

At least Martina is a more current representative of the musical genre than last season's Kenny Rogers, who was almost unrecognizable (i.e., he's had tons of work done).

My question: Will the Top 7 go a little bit country - or full-blown Hank Williams Jr. on me? I'm also curious how strict the "Idol" producers were about song choices. I have a feeling they'll play it safe and stick with more contemporary songs. At least they should.

And please, no chaps and cowboy hats. I know I suggested Sanjaya Malakar wear a Stetson, but I'm backing off that fashion statement.

The competition gets going at 8 tonight (on Channel 40). On Wednesday's results show, Martina will perform her new single, "Anyway." And, yes, it's an hourlong show, so get ready for a hoedown sing-along, more on "Idol Gives Back," copius updates and a surprise or two in the bottom three.

Just to get you fans rattled, I'm throwing Sanjaya and Lakisha Jones in the mix with my predicted eliminated contestant, Phil Stacey.

In other "Idol" news:

* Season 4 winner Carrie Underwood keeps racking up the awards, earning video of the year and female video of the year for the song "Before He Cheats" at Monday night's CMT Music Awards in Nashville. Carrie looked terrific on the red carpet, wearing a strapless Badgley Mischka floral-printed silk taffeta cocktail dress (shown right) with a full short romantic skirt in a warm shade of terracotta.

Even though I thought she looked smashing, I went back and checked out some photos from 2005 as well as some other, more recent awards shows, and Girlfriend is getting painfully thin in my opinion. I know they've got great chicken fried steak in Nashville, so eat up!

* Season 5's Bucky Covington's debut CD, appropriately titled "Bucky Covington," is finally out. Give it a listen and let me know what you Bucky fans think.

* And this e-mail from the NorCal Worden family:

"You crack me up! I’ve been reading your weekly tidbits of 'Idol Chatter' in the paper and decided to stop by the blog today. Oh yeah, it will be one of my daily blog haunts from now on. Thanks so much for the bits and the laughter. This season is entertaining for so many different reasons than last year!"

Posted by Leigh Grogan at 11:01 AM | Comments

April 16, 2007

What's in a name?

Well, if you're "American Idol" contestant Sanjaya Malakar (shown left), it's all about getting the vowels and consonants right.

This just in: Yahoo! Buzz reports that Season 6's most-beloved/most-reviled contestant has achieved yet another dubious honor: He's the most-searched contestant and also the one whose name is most frequently misspelled. He edges out Antonella Barba (Top 24 this year) and last season's rocker/fave Chris Daughtry.

So, how many ways has Sanjaya's first and last name been butchered?

Try 34. They include: Sanjia, Sanjay, Sanjaja, Sangina, Sangaya, Sanjah, Sangria (I love this one!), Sinja, Sonjaya, Malaka, Malacar, Malakr and Malaki.

As for other "Idol" searches, contestant Blake Lewis remains No. 2 on the search list; Phil Stacey is last.

And, across the waters, on the beautiful beaches of Hawaii (where I wish I was right about now), "Idol" worshippers loved Latin week the most.

I say Tri-Cities, Kentucky, will take down the beachcombers after country night on Tuesday.

And Sanjaya definitely should wear a Stetson and some Stetson cologne!

Posted by Leigh Grogan at 01:24 PM | Comments

April 13, 2007

Reality check

Fox/Frank Micelotta

I caught this week's episode of "American Idol Extra" on Fox's Reality Remix show (Direct TV, courtesy of the neighbors), and it really takes you behind the scenes just seconds after the weekly results show ends.

I mean, you're backstage and you see the contestants (Top 7 shown above) come down the steps of the stage - holding hands, crying, smiling, wondering what the heck to say to their ousted competitor.

Good stuff. This week also caught up with Sac's own Mandisa from Season 6 and went to a photo shoot for her upcoming album. She also talked about what else is going on with her (a book, modeling for Ashley Stewart fashions) and performed a song in the Remix mini studio.

Then, Haley Scarnato was interviewed about her elimination and said pretty much what she said Thursday on the conference call with us "Idol" reporters. Again, too much banter about her shorts.

FYI: Judge Simon Cowell was asked on the show about Haley's departure. He said he wasn't surprised. "She was cute. I think we'll put Sanjaya in hot pants next week."

As for the remaining seven, they were polled earlier in the week about what would constitute a romantic evening for them. Here's what they had to say:

* Lakisha Jones: "I set the mood myself."

* Blake Lewis: "Candles, put the music on. It all depends on the lady."

* Jordin Sparks: "I haven't had a romantic evening yet!"

* Phil Stacey: "Definitely Ravel's 'Bolero,' ever since the movie '10.' "

Personal note: I'm curious. That movie, starring Bo Derek and Dudley Moore, came out in 1979. That's 27 years ago, when Phil was, like, 2 years old!!! Guess he got the DVD.

* Melinda Doolittle: "I haven't really had a romantic evening yet."
(OK, Jordin's only 17, but Melinda, at 29, you need some l'amour in your life!)

* Chris Richardson: "The sounds of the sea. Some Christmas music. Maybe a little 'Jingle Bells.' "

* Sanjaya Malakar: "Barry White or Marvin Gaye."

Personal note: OK, the kid is getting suave on me.

You can access a schedule of Reality Remix shows here.

Posted by Leigh Grogan at 11:44 AM | Comments

April 12, 2007

What did Haley have to say?

To answer my own question? Not a whole heck of a lot.

Simply put: Conference calls are not Haley Scarnato's forte, especially after pulling an all-nighter after Wednesday's results show. And, frankly, it wasn't all her fault; the questions that the "Idol" reporters asked revolved too, too much around her leg-baring wardrobe.

Haley, 24, from San Antonio, Texas, was the third of the Top 10 to head home - where she'll be planning her nuptials. (She was scheduled to get married Nov. 10, but the date was moved because of "Idol.")

Unlike last week's eliminated contestant, Gina Glocksen, who was very verbal - and still emotional - about her ouster, Haley seemed vaguely nonplussed during today's teleconference, even throwing out a "Yada, yada, yada ..." at one point.

Anyway, here's what she had to say about her "Idol" experience:

Q: Do you think people mistook your spirited performance for something else?
A: You never can tell. I always tried to do my best. The (Latin) theme was young and youthful. I played to the audience.

Q: What do you think about the comments, especially from (judge) Simon Cowell, about your wardrobe choices?
A: Whether I'm wearing shorts or not, I'm not strutting around. The style of the song ("Turn the Beat Around") is in your face. It has a sexy vibe, and that's what I was going for. Not responding to Simon was the right decision. On national TV, you want to stay in the right frame of mind. It does hurt, but you have to brush it off.

Q: When Simon first started talking about your look, did you consider changing anything?
A: The feedback I got was to keep it. I already had showed my midriff, too, a little. (For the British Invasion theme), I thought about shorts because it was an upbeat song. The show's stylist molded the look together. But I can't please everybody. I didn't go shorter or wear lesser clothes. It's just legs. It is what it is. But it's frustrating because I'm just trying to perform and sing.

Q: Which genre of music will you miss performing?
A: I was looking forward to country music week (next week). I love Faith Hill and Martina McBride (the scheduled guest mentor), and I really wanted to work with her. I was going to wear a choir robe if I was still on the show.

Q: We know the contestants live in a bubble, but have you heard any rumors you'd like to debunk?
A: Not really. We try to stay away from it (gossip) for the sake of our minds. The whole Sanjaya thing - I now hear it's an issue. Sanjaya is a great person. He has a great energy on and off stage.

Q: Who else were you close with? And what about Chris Richardson?
A: Everybody is so supportive. It's a great feeling to know we're there for each other. I want everyone to do well. Chris' chances are so great, and he's a good friend of mine.

Q: What was it like to be in the bottom three again this week?
A: It's tough. It's emotionally draining, but you get through it because you know you do have loyal fans, and I'm grateful for that.

Q: There has been speculation that your hair extensions were recycled and that (runner-up) Katharine McPhee used them last season?
A: Yes, I knew they were hers. It think it's cool because they can wash them.

Q: Which of the mentors did you get the most from?
A: Working with Jennifer Lopez was amazing. She was warm, and she had a lot to tell us. I only spent about 10 minutes with her. We did get to meet Marc Anthony (her husband). You could tell he loves and adores her. I also enjoyed working with Lulu.

Q: Are you looking forward to the tour and any future plans, besides getting married?
A: Absolutely. Just seeing the fans and the excitement they get and we get. I would love to get a record deal. That's what we all want. I'll try anything; we'll see.

Q: What's the first thing you want to do when you return to Texas?
A: I'll definitely eat Mexican food.

Posted by Leigh Grogan at 01:35 PM | Comments

Haley hangs it up

Fox/Frank Micelotta

Maybe America had seen enough - and not heard enough - but eliminating "American Idol" contestant Haley Scarnato (shown above) was the right thing to do.

At last, someone leaves and I'm not shaking my head and spewing expletives!

And, for all you Sanjaya fans out there, he should have stayed, though you better hope he finds another look other than that smarmy, creepy thing he had going Tuesday night.

As for Wednesday's results show, which took an hour instead of the usual 30 minutes, I haven't the vaguest idea why all that filler material was needed. For example, we got:

* A non-intelligible exchange between judges Simon Cowell and Paula Abdul (dressed in gold lame), in which she couldn't speak at all. (Has silly Paula made a comeback?)

* The return of the contestant group medley, which featured Latin music and some really bad dancing.

* A goofy exchange between Simon and host Ryan Seacrest about the winner of the $10,000 "Idol" challenge question, which even a fifth-grader could get right. Something about the winning amount being "nothing to you, rich boy."

* Ryan out and about on the streets of L.A. asking total strangers about which contestants they like. Totally and utterly stupid!

* Singer Akon performing. I didn't get this at all. He performed with Gwen Stefani weeks ago. Why he was back on Latin week ...?

* The weekly Ford commercial. It was one of the better ones, with the Top 8 singing "Happy Together."

* That Celine Dion is joining the growing list of celebrities who will appear on "Idol Gives Back" in two weeks.

* That Eva Longoria ("Desperate Housewives") is in the audience and not in San Antonio, where her fiance, Tony Parker, and the Spurs were picking apart the Sacramento Kings.

Finally, Ryan got around to the business at hand and talks to the Top 8 about their performances and the judges' comments, for instance:

Melinda Doolittle: Simon nailed her for the first time for her rendition of "Sway." She says: "It was tough, but I love his criticism and I respect it. I don't necessarily enjoy it."

Haley: Simon commented that she was wearing fewer clothes to get votes. She says: "I wasn't necessarily offended. It hurts a little. I wouldn't wear something inappropriate. But, it was Latin night."

Stay glued to this space - my Q&A with Haley will be posted later this morning.

Anyway, we find out that more than 35 million votes were cast Tuesday night, and the safety net comes out for Lakisha Jones (she looked shocked), Jordin Sparks, Melinda and Blake Lewis. Phil Stacey ("I just feel blessed!") and Haley are in the bottom three - again. Sanjaya Malakar and Chris Richardson stand and, of course, Chris joins the other two on stage.

Though I agree Chris' "Smooth" from Tuesday wasn't as suave as I think he thought it was, it was easy to send him back to safety. A real no-brainer.

Then, the week's mentor, superstar Jennifer Lopez, was shown hooking up with the contestants earlier this week. She performed "Que Hiciste" off her new album. Now, this is what Randy Jackson was saying about the contestants having a tough time Tuesday night. It takes dancers, fog, lights, pyrotechnics, etc., to make a Latin song come to life.

"The songs were really tough for them," Randy said. "People think they're cool, easy to sing. But you have to connect with the passion. The kids did good."

And so did Jennifer. She's pretty darn mesmerizing. Loved the silver bracelets. Heck, she's just hot! After performing, she told Ryan that she was impressed with the contestants.

"This is such a hard thing," she says. "There's so much pressure to come and do what they do. I take my hat off to them."

There really wasn't much from the judges at this point. Haley and Phil were in this same position last week, only with Gina Glocksen between them. And we all know what craziness ensued then. Gina left!

Wednesday night, Haley didn't really look all that stunned at being eliminated. Unlike Gina, she had a fun farewell song, "Turn the Beat Around." She made the most of her last few minutes on air, actually leaving the stage, mixing it up with the audience and hugging the other contestants.

Next week? The Top 7 hook up with mentor Martina McBride for country week.

Posted by Leigh Grogan at 08:58 AM | Comments

April 11, 2007

Shaken, not stirring

Fox/Frank Micelotta

The Top 8 got a dose of reality, and I don't mean reality TV, on Tuesday during "Latin Night." But, to their credit, this was a genre I feared would rattle them more than any of the previous song stylings.

Let's face it - Latin music is as much about the performance (i.e., the costumes, the staging, the musicians and dancers) as it is about hitting the notes. And, for those of you of a certain genre (read: age), you can relate to the days of Gloria Estefan and the Miami Sound Machine. That was no one-woman staging. It was like something you'd see on Broadway.

That's why singing alone (even with the backup gals) for a minute or so really put these guys and girls at a disadvantage. Even some of the greats, like Melinda Doolittle and Lakisha Jones, took some solid punches from the judges.

And, if you disagree with me on this, I definitely want to hear about it: Blake Lewis (shown above) was without a doubt the best performer. I'll discuss his choice of fashions later.

I thought mentor-of-the-week Jennifer Lopez offered good advice/criticism to the contestants. She really seemed to care that they give it their best shot. And, of course, they were in awe of her. Talk about star power!

Here's what she had to say:

"They all have different types of vibes and styles. To capture the Latin flavor, the key is passion."

Then Jennifer added that, "We watch the show at my house!"

Before I get into rehashing the performances, mark your calendars for the "Idol Gives Back" show in two weeks. Host Ryan Seacrest will offer reminders, adding that even more celebs have signed on to appear, including Rascal Flats and Kelly Clarkson.

So, it's time for the high - and numerous low - notes from Tuesday night's competition:

* Melinda Doolittle: She sang "Sway." Jennifer said she had recorded the song in Spanish. A little research showed others who have covered it include current artists such as Michael Buble and career crooners such as Dean Martin and Rosemary Clooney. So Melinda is somewhere in the sorta middle. Jennifer told her, "You've got a quality I hadn't seen before. You came in with a sultry, sexy side."

Randy Jackson: "These genres are interesting. I was waiting to see what you would do. It was another solid performance. I'm not saying it was your best."

Paula Abdul: "Very sultry, very smooth. You look lovely. You didn't have to wow us, but it was sexy and beautiful."

Simon Cowell: "It had to happen, Melinda. I didn't like it. It's all about personality, and you appeared much older than you are. I found it very lounge-y/cabaret. Lazy and a little bit wooden. I think you're better than that."

Note: Melinda's response: "I'm happy. He (Simon) really wanted to say something bad. I'm glad he got the chance."

Fashion note: Melinda reverted back to a 1950s style, which I thought sort of looked Tropicana Club-esque.

* Lakisha Jones: She sang "Conga" from the Miami Sound Machine. Jennifer told her she was an amazing singer. "She wanted help with her movement, and I told her to ride the rhythm."

Randy: "What I loved is that you were having a good time. It was fun. You made it your own. You threw in those Gloria Estefan runs."

Paula: "You look lovely. It was a real safe Lakisha tonight. It's time to bring out the very best. We all love you."

Simon: "I agree with Paula. It was a fun performance song, but I'm not sure how much everyone at home was having fun. The dancing was not very good."

Note: Lakisha's response: "It went out of my comfort zone."

Fashion note: The stylists had Lakisha in a dress that really was too, well, "conga-ish" for her.

* Chris Richardson: He sang "Smooth," the Santana song with Rob Thomas. Jennifer urged Chris to work on his Spanish pronounciation so as not to offend the Latino audience. "Originally, it was too low for him, so I made him reach for it. That's the key for him."

Randy: "I was wondering at first (about this choice) because Carlos Santana and Rob Thomas, they laid it out. You did a really good job. Very cool, dawg."

Paula: "A hot performance. What am I going to say? It was sexy."

Simon: "Not the best vocal I've ever heard, but I preferred it to the first two (performers). It felt more contemporary. Theirs were more hotel cabaret. It was a good performance."

* Haley Scarnato: She sang "Turn the Beat Around," another Estefan song, which definitely requires numerous props and a big, big beat. Jennifer said, "It's hard to sing, and it's all about rhythm. You have to bite the words. It's almost like a rap. You have to throw it at the people." Then she brought in beat-boxing contestant Blake Lewis to help Haley get the, uh, beat.

Randy: "If I'm keeping it real, it really didn't work for me. That could be heard in any bar, any place. I just didn't get that at all."

Paula: "It's not a singer's song, but it is a fun song. And you had fun."

Simon: "At the moment, you've got a very good tactic: Wear the least amount of clothes as possible. You can't do well based on your voice. There are other (contestants) with better vocals. All you can do here is have fun. The vocals were so rushed at the end I couldn't understand what you were singing."

Note: Haley's response: "I appreciate all the judges. I had fun. It was a great song, and I got the audience going."

Fashion note: I agree with Haley. She did indeed get the audience going, but it was more about being a vixen, not a vocalist. I'm now waiting for Lloyd's of London to call and sell her gam insurance based on yet another hot pants performance.

* Phil Stacey: He sang "Maria, Maria," another Santana song. Jennifer advised him to think of someboy, anybody, to get into the mood of the song. (Last week, Phil thought of his wife - and almost regretted it.) "He did give me goose pimples," Jennifer said. Really??!!

Randy: "I don't know if it was your best performance. It didn't quite connect with the passion."

Paula: "It was a really good vocal - except at the end."

Simon: "Phil, you're a nice guy. You chose a good song, but there was no originality. I thought it was flat, lifeless. Your voice cracked at the end. I couldn't get positive or excited."

Note: Phil's response: His baby daughter has a stuffed cow appropriately named "Simon Cow."

Note from me: Just like last week's "Night and Day," this week's "Maria, Maria" found several of us "Idol" worshippers checking for a pulse.

* Jordin Sparks: She sang "The Rhythm is Gonna Get You," another Estefan number. Jennifer said, "She has such a sweet voice. It reminded me of Michael Jackson." (Er, not sure where that came from). Jennifer encouraged Jordin to give it some soul and to rock it.

Randy: "Absolutely wonderful and great. To see somebody at age 17, that was the Yo factor! A blast."

Paula: "I loved that you're so authentic. You're just out there having a good time."

Simon: "They're just OK performances tonight. Nothing stunning. I haven't seen a progression (in talent), and that's frustrating because you're a good singer."

Fashion note: Again, again, Jordin is only 17, yet her look was too dated, especially the black "mom" pants.

* Blake Lewis: He sang "I Need To Know." This is a Marc Anthony song. That would be Jennifer's husband. "It has to mean something and come from somewhere. If not, it leaves people vacant." Then, Jennifer tells Blake, "I want to see you pick that girl up."

Note: Yes, Blake does need a new girlfriend. He and his significant other broke up before he got to "Idol."

Randy: "Best song choice of the night! Hot performance, dawg!"

Paula: "Very smart performance. It totally captured who you are. Excellent choice."

Simon: "Blake, it was the best choice of song tonight. The best performance so far."

Fashion note: I agree completely, but I want to see Blake take his style up a notch. Dude, did you just bring tennis shoes to Hollywood?

* Sanjaya Malakar: He sang "Besame Mucho," which, loosely translated, can mean "Kiss Me Much," "Kiss Me a Lot" or "Kiss Me Again and Again." Jennifer says it's a beautiful, Spanish song. Of Sanjaya: "He really, really impressed me. I love Sanjaya! He needs to take his time. Don't rush it. It's a good choice for him. Simon might even be impressed!"

Randy: "You are one of the smartest contestants I've ever met. It was really good!

Paula: "Smooth - very, very nice."

Simon: "Right. I couldn't understand a word of it. You sang like a 14-year-old. I'm going to hate myself for this, but it wasn't that horrible."

Note from Ryan Seacrest: He's now referring to Sanjaya as, well, just plain "Sanjaya" - no Malakar.

Note about other notable artists who covered this song: The Beatles, Andrea Bocelli, the Flamingos, Trini Lopez and, my favorite, Connie Francis, who Sanjaya most resembled - except for the freshly grown moustache.

Predictions: At Dialidol.com, they've got Blake safe. Behind him, Melinda and Phil are close; Haley, Sanjaya and Chris are next; Jordin and Lakisha are at the bottom of the voting.

As for me, I haven't gotten it right since Stephanie Edwards got expelled. So, I'll go for the jugular and say Lakisha goes home tonight. That's one shaky limb I'm sitting on.

The results show commences at 9 tonight on Channel 40. Jennifer Lopez will show us how Latin is really done!

Posted by Leigh Grogan at 09:48 AM | Comments

April 10, 2007

What are the odds of this?

Fox/Michael Becker

Could it get any more perplexing this season?

Almost 33 million votes were cast after last week's competition, which narrowed it down to the Top 8 contestants (shown above). Now, it looks like an online gambling site, Gambling911.com, which you can visit here, has favored performer Lakisha Jones at risk of being eliminated this week.

What?!

Now, I'm not good with odds, but the site repeats what I've feared for a couple of weeks: that Lakisha and Melinda Doolittle are too similar in their song stylings and that one could cancel out the other.

Payton O'Brien, the site's "Idol" observer, says Lakisha does not project herself in the same manner as Melinda.

"Lakisha Jones was highly touted early on - not only for her voice, but for the fact that she was a single mom - and this tender aspect of her life has hardly been mentioned over the past few weeks, while Doolittle is always projected as the backup vocalist with the powerful voice and little belief she can actually become the next 'American Idol,' "Payton says.

"I think America overall can relate to Doolittle better since so many of us require that boost of self-confidence."

Still, Haley Scarnato and Phil Stacey are lurking around in the lower echelons. And I think tonight's star/genre - Jennifer Lopez and Latin music - should elicit some interesting, if not pointed (read: nasty) comments, from the three judges.

Meanwhile, the Nielsens just landed for last week:

"American Idol" finished first last Tuesday (competition show), with 26.6 million viewers, and second last Wednesday (results show), with 26.1 million viewers.

If you're a reality-show junkie, check out my story in Wednesday's Scene on how the two top-rated reality shows - "American Idol" and "Dancing With the Stars" - square off against one another.

Posted by Leigh Grogan at 02:13 PM | Comments

April 09, 2007

JLo on the 'Idol' set

Ray Mickshaw /Fox

The mix of mentors on "American Idol" continues to amaze me. Whether you think the contestants are hitting the right notes, you have to admire the show for getting some uber-talented celebs to show up each week.

OK, so it is a chance for said celebs to plug an upcoming tour or recently released CD. Such is the case this week with superstar Jennifer Lopez, shown above, who is working with the Elite 8 finalists on a Latin-themed competition.

The four guys/four girls will compete at 8 p.m. Tuesday. Then, on Wednesday, JLo will perform her new single, “Qué Hiciste,” on the results show at 9 p.m. Unless, that is, she gets the flu bug, which prevented last week's mentor, Tony Bennett, from performing.

Jennifer recently released her first all-Spanish album, “Como Ama Una Mujer” (How a Woman Loves), so she's got some incentive to show up.

Note to you: By the way, I got a whiff of Jennifer's newest fragrance, Glow After Dark. Head over to my other favorite blog, 21Q and get the scoop on the scent and its online reality show.

As for how "Idol's" Top 8 will cut it with this theme, I like Jordin Sparks' chances, as well as Chris Richardson's.

As for silly Sanjaya Malakar, check out this e-mail to Idol Chatter from Adrienne in Sacramento:

"Why is he still there?????? He was kept in the Top 10 to get the 12-year-old girls to come to the ('Idol') tour. But now I really don't know why he's there. Help!"

And then there's this from Marsha in Sacramento:

"I am so tired of people feeling sorry for poor, talentless Sanjaya since he's only 17. Don't people realize that fantastically talented Jordin Sparks is also 17 and could possibly be one of the Top 5!? People who keep voting for Sanjaya are making a mockery of 'American Idol' and hurting the talented contestants."

Love him or loathe him, Yahoo! Buzz reports today that Sanjaya not only has more searches than this week’s guest star, JLo, but "he has become the most-searched male celebrity in the past seven days, bypassing Yahoo! regulars Justin Timberlake, Chris Brown and even Harry Potter."

Posted by Leigh Grogan at 03:04 PM | Comments

April 05, 2007

She'll rock on!

Haley Scarnato and Gina Glocksen share a hug after Gina is eliminated.
Michael Becker/Fox

Gina Glocksen says she has no regrets - about anything. Her song choices, her style, even her tongue ring.

The latest contestant to be eliminated from "American Idol" spoke to reporters today and, despite her obvious disappointment, she says she'll keep singing.

"I showed America I have a voice, not just a rocker image," she says. "I wouldn't have done it any other way."

As a member of the "Idol" Top 10, Gina, 22, from Naperville, Ill., will be hitting the road this summer as part of a nationwide tour, which she says she's really looking forward to.

Here's what else she had to say:

Q: Are you second-guessing the decision to mellow out by singing "Smile" on Tuesday?

A: I loved this song, but I never thought I'd be singing it again on Wednesday because I wasn't preparing to go home. I didn't have a chance to be in the bottom three, ever. When I started to sing it last night, it kind of clicked: 'Wow, I'm actually singing about myself.' So it will be a very special song for me the rest of my life.

Q: Do you think this week's musical genre hurt you?

A: You can't rock out Tony Bennett. I think my fans were proud of my last two performances. Maybe they thought I would be safe and didn't vote as much.

Q: Which genre will you miss performing? And which genre did you enjoy most while on the show?

A: Definitely Bon Jovi. I would have sang "Livin' on a Prayer." I got a lot from Diana Ross. Not necessarily about vocals, but about this industry. She talked about people telling you what to sing, what to wear and how it's important to choose one person, trust them and give them everything you have.

Q: What do you think America is looking for this season?

A: I have a track record, which I think counts for a lot. But, at the end of the day, you don't know what America wants. Is it talent, personality, your style, your hair, your clothes? You have to stay true to yourself. That's what will get you far.

Q: What impact, if any, do you think having a tongue ring influenced voting?

A: I would hope (voters) focused on singing talent and song choices. If that (ring) was the reason they didn't vote, well, it's who I am. I took the ring out for two shows, then put it back in.

Q: What do you think about all the hoopla surrounding Sanjaya Malakar? Are you surprised he's still in the competition?

A: It's tough that all the other eight made it through, not just him. He's just different. Not better or worse. America was through with me. There hasn't been any grumbling. People are pretty fair about what they say in front of each other. They know not to bad-mouth Sanjaya in front of me. He's hanging in there and not letting it get to him.

Q: How much of what's said about this group are you guys picking up on?

A: We're pretty sheltered from the things that are being said about us because it could affect our performances. They ("Idol" folks) warn us about going on the Internet. It's to our own caution that we don't read it, so I stay away from it.

Q: How do you feel you were treated by the judges? And what did they tell you last night?

A: I kind of considered Simon (Cowell) a parent. That tough love kind of thing. They tell you what you don't want to hear, and you'll do the opposite. He wanted to push me to the next level. Randy (Jackson) said if I had sang "Smile" the way I did last night on Tuesday, I would still be here! Paula (Abdul) told me she was a fan and "You're a star." Simon said he really, really liked me and was glad I went back to my rocker image.

Q: Will you stick with that image?

A: I love rock music, but I also think I'm very versatile with the (musical) genres. After the tour, I want to move to L.A., get a record deal and make my own music. I won't be doing covers anymore.

Q: Who will you miss most?

A: Honest to God, we've been told we're the most close group. Like one big family. There's no resentment. We all get along. Chris (Richardson) and I have formed a strong bond. He'll go far. I'm great friends with Haley (Scarnato), too. I'm glad to see her there. I wish I was there, too!"

Q: How do you come up with all your looks each week?

A: We have a great team of stylists. They're amazing. They dress us, do our hair. It's such an art for them, and they get to know us on a personal basis. Who would have thought I would wear fishnets singing Tony Bennett?

Q: Do you and Sanjaya compete for hairdos?

A: It's like another competition for who has the better hair. I think my best hairdo through the episodes was when I sang "I'll Stand By You." It was long in the front, covering my face.

Q: How difficult is it to have gone through this process four times and now be eliminated?

A: It's amazing. Actually, I'm glad I got cut earlier (in the previous auditions). It gave me time to work on things, like timing. I took some vocal lessons in Chicago, especially how to make my voice work with different genres.

Q: What did you think when the audience started booing last night when you were eliminated?

A: It made me feel so blessed and very much loved. It was hard to see all the signs. It's just a treasure to have the fans. It was bittersweet.

Q: Did Mr. Pickle let you down?

A: I'm a little upset with him. But, he got me this far."

Posted by Leigh Grogan at 11:49 AM | Comments

A surprise ending

Michael Becker/Fox

I shed several tears at the conclusion of Wednesday night's results show. OK, so I wept openly.

I don't know about you guys, but seeing Gina Glocksen (shown above) eliminated was painful, especially with her family shouting "We love you!" in the audience. And Gina, who was obviously devastated, pulled it together to sing what might have been one of the toughest, saddest farewell songs in "Idol" history - "Smile," the song she sang during Tuesday night's competition.

Don't get me wrong. I knew going into Wednesday night that Sanjaya Malakar would be safe, but Gina really wasn't on my get-the-boot radar. I had Phil Stacey or even Haley Scarnato pegged to head home.

The show started with host Ryan Seacrest doing the usual opening announcements, which always reminds me of the principal on the loud speaker in high school. There was one interesting tidbit. Apparently "Idol" is launching an amateur songwriting contest. If you've got lyrics and a tune floating around in your head, you can submit it. The winning song will be performed at this season's grand finale in May. Details at www.americanidol.com.

After the weekly "Idol" Ford commercial (sung to "One Love"), the show returned with the Final 9 divided into groups of three: Blake Lewis, Chris Richardson and Sanjaya; Haley, Gina and Phil; and Jordin Sparks, Melinda Doolittle and Lakisha Jones.

Now it didn't take a rocket scientist to figure out the plan here. The last three girls were safe (they were the top three), and the first three guys were also safe (mostly because Sanjaya was among them). That left Haley, Gina and Phil in the bottom three. Easy.

This is the part of the show where the week's guest mentor - that would be Tony Bennett - normally performs. But Tony was hit with a flu bug, so Michael Buble stepped in and did a fine job with "Call Me Irresponsible," off his upcoming album.

Afterward, Michael asked Ryan if he was wasting his time voting for Antonella Barba. Er, yes, Michael.

Then it was time for Ryan to send one of the bottom three to safety. The audience screamed "Gina! Gina!" - and rightly so. But it was Phil who returned to the waiting arms of the six survivors.

Ryan then asked the judges what they thought:

Randy Jackson: "I'm a little surprised about both of them."

Paula Abdul: "It gets tough at this stage. I don't know. This is hard."
(Then she admonished Simon Cowell for smiling, which he was doing.)

Simon: "I'm not surprised."

Like Chris Sligh last week, Haley had the look of someone who thought it was her time to go. Heck, she was in the same spot with him. But it was Gina who got the bad news. She and Haley both were in tears, and that's when I lost it because I knew there was enough time left for Gina to sing that sad song.

Ryan told her she should be proud of herself and even picked up the stuffed green pickle (her lucky charm) that Gina had dropped on the stage. Gina told the audience - and viewers: "I'll see you on the tour. Thanks for getting me this far."

And big props to rocker girl for singing her song and smiling all the way through. The lyrics alone had to be challenging:

"Smile, though your heart is breaking. Smile, even though it's aching."

The Final 8 contestants were pretty shaken, especially the girls. They joined Gina on stage for the last couple of bars.

I'm not sure exactly what happened here. I talked with one "Idol" fan who said he thought the genre of music hurt her. I think her fans didn't protect her by voting and that's why she left.

Stay glued to this space - my Q&A with Gina will be posted later this morning.

Next week's mentor? Jennifer Lopez and Latin stylings.

Posted by Leigh Grogan at 08:18 AM | Comments

April 04, 2007

The best of Bennett

Frank Micelotta/Fox

I think it's sad when the one "American Idol" who was looking forward the most to performing a Tony Bennett song ended up having the worst night.

That would be Phil Stacey.

He performed second on Tuesday night's show, gushing that Tony "is my hero," and that he has been waiting eagerly for the legendary singer to coach the contestants.

For his part, Bennett, who by age 80 has earned 15 Grammy Awards, said the Top 9 were all competent. "They'll be singing songs and telling stories, the best ever written in America. This music will never go out of style."

Still, I don't know if this was my favorite night. I certainly was looking forward to it for several reasons: I love Bennett's latest CD, and I was pretty sure I would know the songs the nine would perform. No need for iTunes.

In my opinion, the five girls definitely outsung the remaining four guys. But not by much. Interestingly, most of the contestants received generally favorable critiques from the judges. So let's get to it.

* Blake Lewis: He sang "Mack the Knife." Tony said he needed to get into the "meaning of the song. This is sort of pre-rap, soft gangster. Think of that and slow down the tempo."

Blake does that "Blake-ize" thing, where he puts a little cool-cat touch on his performances. I liked it.

Randy Jackson: "That was a good start. Way to bring that cool, funky jazz vibe. There were a couple of pitch problems. But I liked it. I always wait to see what you're going to do."

Paula Abdul: "You personified pizazz. You're a hip cat. Fun and cool."

Simon Cowell: "Good choice of song. Good performance. I give you a seven out of 10. I give the band an eight out of 10."

Fashion note: Blake set the tone for men's footwear last night. Too many tennies.

* Phil Stacey: He sang "Night and Day." Tony told him to put a little beat behind it. "He's one of the better singers I've heard," he added.

I didn't think Phil put any beat into this performance. I thought it was downright dreary. Am I still awake?

Randy: "An interesting choice. You sang it good. The big notes were cool for you, but I didn't feel any real compassion or connection."

Paula: "The good news is you're reminiscent of a young Frank Sinatra. I still need you to have more joy. Warm up those vocals first."

Simon: (to Paula) "Which Frank Sinatra are you referring to? It had all the joy of someone singing in a funeral parlor. It was completely gloomy, slightly dark. I thought there was no life in the performance."

Note from Phil: "I was trying to focus on my wife."

* Melinda Doolittle (above): She sang "I've Got Rhythm." Tony said Melinda has a big chance in the music business. "She's the best singer I've heard all day."

As for me: Loved the dress and heels. Loved the song. Love Melinda.

Randy: "Do you know what I love? Every week, you come out and give everyone a lesson in singing. You interpret the lyrics. This is how you do it, America!"

Paula: "It's like a master class. Every song has a beginning, middle and end. You're ready for CDS, concert halls, No. 1s."

Simon: "The beginning was a bit cabaret. The second half was great. It had personality. It was fun. I don't think we'll ever be able to criticize you. And I think this is a problem."

Note from host Ryan Seacrest: "Why do you have to find something to criticize?" From Simon: "We like being mean to people occasionally."

* Chris Richardson: He sang "Don't Get Around Much Anymore." Tony said he really, really needed to memorize the song (natch), "so you don't miss the lyrics."

Chris was Chris - cute, fun, playful. And, yes, he remembered the words!

Randy: "What's cool about you is you come out with a vengeance. This was one of your best performances this season. It was cool, young, hip and hot."

Paula: "You've got true artistic integrity. You made it your own style."

Simon: "I thought it was very good, very believeable. You made it kind of hip. It was probably one of the strongest we'll hear tonight."

Fashion note: I'm not sure I liked the drooping suspenders with the Bing Crosby hat and the torn jeans with the sneakers.

* Jordin Sparks: She sang "On a Clear Day," because it's such a "really cute song." Tony said she was terrific. "She sang in tune, which is rare today. She's intelligent. She improvised and changed a note here and there."

Jordin continues her youthful march, but for some reason, I kept thinking/seeing Barbra Streisand while she was performing.

Randy: "Here's what I love and like now. There are nine people left, and we've got some heat up there (on the stage). You sing like a pro, and you're only 17...That was the bomb!"

Paula: "You're a magnet of joy, and you exude it on stage. I'm so frickin' proud of you! You're going to sail through to the next round."

Simon: "You sung it very well. But you didn't do what Chris did before you. You didn't make it young and current. It was more traditional and a little old-fashioned."

Hair note: I like Jordin best with her curly coif.

* Gina Glocksen: She sang "Smile." Tony said, "This song gives you hope in your darkest moment. It's simple but great. When I hear it, I think of
9/11 and Iraq, and I pray the soldiers come home."

You knew right off this was going to be a deviation in mood and manner for Gina, and she pulled it off. I loved the softer makeup (silver eye shadow) and her braided red highlights.

Randy: "Very nice. It was a controlled performance for the rocker girl."

Paula: "It was flawless and understated. Beautiful sentiment."

Simon: "I can't rave about the vocals. Two girls came on before you and completely outsung you."

Note from Gina: "You have to aim for you own personal best."

* Sanjaya Malakar: He sang "Cheek to Cheek." Ryan introduced him by saying, "Let's see what happens when two legends meet face to face." Loved it! Tony said, "I'm a big fan of yours." He added that Sanjaya dares to be different and that's what makes him interesting. So Tony has been following the season!

Sanjaya said his goal was to make America see that "I can sing." Bring it, dude!

Randy: "I can't even comment on the vocals anymore. You've turned into a great entertainer. All the different hairstyles, the suit."

Paula: "I get why people love you. There's this charm about you. But I'm not sure if it was 'Dancing With the Stars' or 'American Idol.' "

Simon: "Let's try a different tactic this week: It was incredible!"

Performance and fashion notes: Sanjaya slicked back his hair (which I predicted), wore a white suit and tennies, and engaged Paula in a dance while he was singing. Thus the reference to "Dancing With the Stars." Ryan said Sanjaya was staying under the radar.

* Haley Scarnato: She sang "I'm Saving My Love for You." Tony reminded her she was singing the song for one person, not several guys. "You can't make that promise to more than one person. It doesn't make sense."

Decked out in a sparkly green low-cut, high-cut dress, Haley appeared to be doing her part to fight global warming. However, it seemed she was just getting all the males heated up with this performance.

Randy: "I thought this might be a good week for you because it fits in with your vibe."

Paula: "Did I mention green is a good color for you?"

Simon: "I think you've got great legs. A good style of music for you, but I thought it was a little pageant-like."

A personal note: Haley will definitely stick around this week. When she goes, I see a Candies shoe ad in her future.

* Lakisha Jones: She sang "Stormy Weather." Tony said, "She's very good." He advised Lakisha to alter the end of the song and go for the big note.

It was vintage Lakisha. I mean, who is going to bump off her or Melinda? I know - Sanjaya!

Randy: "I love this. It was the perfect song for you. It was a little pitchy in the front, but it was the bomb in the end."

Paula: "It's the most gorgeous you've looked. It proves we all love Tony Bennett, and we love you!"

Simon: "That was a sassy, great performance."

Program note: Simon didn't get to say much because the show was running late.

Predictions: Right now, DialIdol.com only shows Melinda as being totally safe; the rest are too close to call. I'm going with Phil making a hasty exit tonight, with perhaps Haley standing next to him - and safe again - in a really short dress.

Posted by Leigh Grogan at 10:13 AM | Comments

April 03, 2007

Tony teaches 'em

Ray Mickshaw /Fox

For those "American Idol" fans of, shall we say a certain age, tonight's competition, featuring the classic stylings of legendary crooner Tony Bennett (shown above with the Top 9), should be a beaut. Nine contestants. Nine songs. Finally, I'm not worried about not knowing the tunes.

Interestingly, I found out during a conference call with "Idol" Executive Producer Ken Warwick earlier today that some of the "kids," er, contestants didn't know the Bennett standards. Sure, give 'em Mute Math and they're pumped. But Tony, and they go, "Duh, who?!"

Anyway, US Weekly magazine recently conducted an "Idol" poll with a mishmash of questions. One asked which singer folks are most excited to see coach the contestants.

Answer: last week's mentor Gwen Stefani (48 percent). Tony finished dead last, at 5 percent. Next week's mentor, Jennifer Lopez, came in second, at 24 percent.

Come on! Lakisha Jones can belt out "The Best Is Yet To Come." And how about big-voiced Melinda Doolittle with "The Good Life"? Sorry to say, it probably will be the youngsters - Sanjaya Malakar, maybe Jordin Sparks - who might have the most trouble. I could be wrong, of course.

I say Sanjaya should go with "Put On a Happy Face." That won't be much of a stretch for him. And, what about a slicked-back, sauve hairstyle to go with it? Maybe even a tuxedo jacket, with tails and tattered jeans. The younger girls will love it! Maybe even shed a tear or two!

By the way, Warwick says that it's pure speculation on his part as to who exactly is keeping Sanjaya in the contest.

"I see the reaction of the young girls," he says. "There is something in human nature that makes people gravitate toward someone who's good-looking."

Warwick actually came to Sanjaya's defense, adding that (even though he doesn't think it will happen) if Sanjaya makes it to the end, it will be because the public wants to see more of him, not because some Web site is influencing the vote. And, besides, he thinks Sanjaya has a good voice.

"The thing about Sanjaya is that he's no different from the others," Warwick says. "If the judges give him a hard time, fans vote to spoil it. Controversy is good for the show."

Warwick says that there is a mechanism that has been in place since the beginning of "American Idol" to identify giant blocks of voting. And while he admits there's voting congestion at the local levels (not so much at the national), the equipment has never been used.

"Only four people know the voting results," he says. "We don't reveal the specific numbers because it can sway people. It's only important to know who got the lowest number of votes."

Other tidbits from Warwick:

* On judge Simon Cowell's threat to leave the show if Sanjaya wins: "Simon is full of it. Would you walk away from that much money? He'll be here. Don't worry. Besides, America normally gets it right in the end."

* On how much influence the judges have: "They do influence viewers. Sometimes they go too far, and viewers bring them back to Earth. For example, when Simon told Haley (Scarnato) she was insignificant and he couldn't even remember her name, it was harsh and uncalled for. Viewers said, 'Screw you, Simon.' That week, she was way up (in the voting). The public often puts them (the judges) in their place."

* On how well the musical genres are working this season: "The obvious genres have been done. It's best if you can open them out and still have the desired effect. It gives (the contestants) something to think about."

* On how the other contestants are reacting to the "Sanjaya Factor": "Everybody is happy, provided they stay on the show. There's no real grumbling among them. Actually, they're quite fascinated by it. Any votes for or against him generally won't have any impact on the general number of votes. We told them what to expect. Not to go on the Web sites because they might see a picture taken on spring break.

"We aren't judgmental about it at all. But they were warned upfront about the problems associated with this notoriety. Some just aren't ready for it."

Meanwhile, this just in: The Nielsen ratings for last week arrived today, and "Idol" is still at the top of the TV heap:

1. “American Idol” (Tuesday competition), 28.18 million viewers.
2. “American Idol” (Wednesday results show), 26.89 million viewers.

Based on the below-30-million viewer mark, it makes me wonder if Season 6 is just idling along - no pun intended, of course. Your thoughts?

On a completely unrelated topic because they're not butting heads this week, but the "Dancing With the Stars" hourlong results show will not be shown at 9 tonight on Channel 10 because of a Kings game. Instead, it will air at the improbable hour of 1 a.m.! (See my colleague Sam McManis' blog at my other favorite blog, 21Q.)

At least on "Dancing,"