FOX
If you're a fan of the female contestants on "American Idol," my guess is you'll seeanother one go home on tonight's results show. Funny thing is, judge Simon Cowell predicted this would be a girl's season to win.
Not so fast there, Simon.
After last night's R&B/soul show, the Top 10 will likely be whittled down to six guys and three girls. I believe it's Didi Benami's turn to exit stage right. Her performance of "What Becomes of the Brokenhearted" pretty much was as judge Randy Jackson said: "It flatlined." Simon said it was like "swimming in jelly - old-fashioned and off melody." For me, Didi has cried her last tear.
The best performances? No question Lee Dewyze (pictured) elevated from just a Dave Matthews-wannabe to Bruce Springsteen-esque. "Treat Her Like a Lady" is one of my favorite songs, and I can't recall anyone singing it as good as the original by the Cornelius Brothers and Sister Rose. But Lee nailed it.
Simon said: "I want you tonight to go home, watch the show back and understand this is the night your life may have changed forever." Ellen DeGeneres, a fan of Lee from the get-go, said it was the best performance of the night.
Andrew Garcia, who hasn't been able to find his musical footing since Hollywood Week, rallied with a great version of Chris Brown's "Forever." His mom even gave Simon a hug.
My early favorite, Crystal Bowersox, gave me a scare when she hit the stage in stilettos instead of bare feet, her guitar traded in for a piano and "Midnight Train to Georgia." She can sing the phone book, but I hope the show's stylists/producers don't try to sanitize Crysal with too much makeup and jewelry. She's one contestant who definitely needs to stay true to herself. And ease off the backup singers!
I liked Casey James, who should be safe with a nice take on the Sam and Dave classic "Hold On." Even though I'm fond of young Aaron Kelly, "Ain't No Sunshine" ain't got much going for it. And remember, last season's winner Kris Allen sang this song with a very good version, which is hard to top.
Mentor Usher was terrific with the contestants, offering sound advice that made a difference in several performances, including Big Michael Lynche, whose "Ready for Love" (India Arie) was heartfelt. Katie Stevens also listened to Usher, but reverted to her old ways of picking old songs. Thumbs down on an Aretha fave, "Chain of Fools." I agree with the judges that it had a "Star Search" feel.
And what can we say about Tim Urban, who is now affectionately dubbed "Teflon Tim?" He sang Anita Baker's "Sweet Love," which was just, well, gooey. Kara DioGuardi said it had a "Broadway/Vegas take. You took the soul out of the song." But props to Tim. He just takes the judges' punches and rolls with them.
The other female contestant who has really impressed but seems to be veering off the musical highway is Siobhan Magnus. She performed first (the worst spot of the night because you get the most verbage from the judges), singing "Through the Fire." She looked scared to death, and sang waaaay off key. Simon said it sounded like she was running a marathon while singing and "running out of breath." Siobhan took the criticism hard and was in tears afterward.
It's bizarro, but I really don't care about seeing the judges coming back from a break as they walked backstage. It felt like waiting outside a bathroom.
Tonight, Usher will perform, someone will go home, the evening will see tears and jeers and nine will remain. Stay tuned.



![jc0006[1].jpg](http://www.sacbee.com/static/weblogs/ticket/jc0006%5B1%5D.jpg)

![crocetto%20headshot[1].jpg](http://www.sacbee.com/static/weblogs/ticket/crocetto%2520headshot%5B1%5D.jpg)


