Sacramento Bee Logo

Judge rejects pledge in school | The Sacramento Bee

×
  • E-edition
    • Customer Service
    • SacBee Rewards
    • About Us
    • About Us
    • Contact Us
    • Apps
    • Mobile & Apps
    • Twitter, Facebook, Google+, YouTube
    • News in Education (NIE)
  • Newsletters

    • Sacramento Region
    • Arena
    • City Beat
    • Crime
    • Local Govt Salary Database
    • The Homeless
    • Marcos Bretón
    • Transportation
    • Education
    • Environment
    • Health & Medicine
    • Traffic Conditions
    • Weather
    • Communities
    • Elk Grove
    • Folsom/El Dorado
    • Roseville/Placer
    • Yolo
    • Sports
    • Kings
    • NBA News
    • 49ers
    • Giants
    • Oakland A's
    • High School Sports
    • Joe Davidson
    • More Sports
    • Raiders
    • NFL News
    • MLB News
    • River Cats
    • Soccer
    • Colleges
    • Golf
    • Autos Racing
    • Politics
    • Capitol Alert
    • State Workers
    • The California Influencer Series
    • Local Elections
    • PoliGRAPH
    • State Worker Salary Database
    • Legislative Gifts
    • Local Elections
    • California Elections
    • Election Endorsements
    • Election 2018
    • Voter Guide
    • Investigations
    • Data Tracker
    • Public Eye
    • Afghan Refugees
    • Nursing Homes
    • Opinion
    • Editorials
    • Election Endorsements
    • Viewpoints
    • Influencers Opinion
    • California Forum
    • Letters to the Editor
    • Submit a Letter
    • Jack Ohman
    • Editorial Board
    • Entertainment & Life
    • Arts & Theater
    • Books
    • Home & Garden
    • Movies
    • Music
    • Outdoors
    • Pets
    • Travel
    • More Entertainment
    • Events Calendar
    • Horoscopes
    • Comics
    • Puzzles
    • TV Listings
    • Sacbee Rewards
    • Food & Drink
    • Restaurants News & Reviews
    • Restaurant Directory
    • Cooking & Recipes
    • Beer
    • Wine
    • Appetizers Blog
    • California
    • Big Valley
    • Marijuana
    • Wildfires
    • Water & Drought
    • Lottery
    • Business
    • Real Estate
    • Market Summary
    • Cathie Anderson
    • Nation & World
    • National
    • World
    • Technology
    • Family
    • Celebrities
    • TV news
    • Weird News
    • Video Break
    • News Obituaries
    • Death Notices
    • FAQ
    • ObitMessenger
    • In Memoriam

    • The Sacramento Bee Store
    • Golf Card
    • Farm to Fork Dining Card
  • Jobs
  • Moonlighting
  • Cars
  • Homes
  • Classifieds
  • Legal Notices
  • Place an Ad
  • Advertise
  • Mobile & Apps

Latest News

Judge rejects pledge in school

By Denny Walsh and Crystal Carreon -- Bee Staff Writers

    ORDER REPRINT →

September 15, 2005 08:05 AM

Reciting the Pledge of Allegiance in a school classroom is unconstitutionally coercive, a Sacramento federal judge ruled Wednesday.

Saying he is bound by a 2003 federal appellate opinion, U.S. District Judge Lawrence K. Karlton found that teachers leading students in reciting the pledge, which contains the words "under God," is a violation of the Constitution's mandated separation of religion and government.

The suit was filed by Michael Newdow, a Sacramento atheist, physician and non-practicing attorney, on behalf of himself and two families whose children attend Sacramento-area schools.

As part of a 30-page order, Karlton invited Newdow to file a motion for an injunction that would bar students from reciting the pledge in the three school districts named as defendants in the suit. If Newdow asks for an injunction, Karlton said he would issue one.

Sign Up and Save

Get six months of free digital access to The Sacramento Bee

SUBSCRIBE WITH GOOGLE

#ReadLocal

The ruling was met with surprise and disappointment among school district officials.

"I think for purposes of schoolchildren, teachers, principals, administrators, school districts across the country ... it should be decided, for once and for all, whether the pledge recited by schoolchildren on a voluntary basis is constitutional," said Terence Cassidy, the attorney representing the three districts, Elk Grove Unified, Elverta Joint Elementary and Rio Linda.

District officials said they will consider taking the matter all the way to the U.S. Supreme Court for the second time, if necessary.

In the meantime, students who choose to recite the pledge will be permitted to do so until a court order bars the daily exercise, said Steven Ladd, superintendent of Elk Grove schools.

"We will continue to follow the law on whether or not our students may recite the pledge," he said.

On Wednesday afternoon, Elk Grove school officials sent an e-mail to principals stating that the pledge could still be recited in classrooms.

Quoting from the 2003 opinion of the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, Karlton said that, even without requiring each child to recite the pledge, their "mere presence in the classroom every day as peers recite the statement 'one nation under God' has a coercive effect."

The appellate court said that the "coercive effect of the policy here is particularly pronounced in the school setting given the age and impressionability of schoolchildren."

Newdow originally sued because he objected to his daughter being exposed to the pledge each day in her Elk Grove classroom. The Supreme Court found that because he didn't have primary custody of his daughter, he didn't have standing to sue.

Newdow, who was the lone plaintiff in that suit, filed a second suit that included two other families.

In that original case, the high court did not address the 9th Circuit's conclusion concerning the Elk Grove Unified School District's policy with respect to reciting the pledge, and Karlton said that part of the 9th Circuit's opinion is still precedent he must follow.

"It's unfortunate that the District Court has decided to simply follow the previous ruling by the 9th Circuit, rather than to review this matter anew," Cassidy said.

On Wednesday morning, before news of Karlton's ruling reached school district officials, about 30,000 elementary students in Elk Grove recited the pledge, including 7-year-old Ian Hamilton. "I like saying it," said Ian, a second-grader at Ellen Feickert Elementary School. "It just means the heart of America."

After school, a few parents agreed that school resources could best be spent elsewhere instead of defending the suit.

Elk Grove parent Lynda Bettencourt defended reciting the pledge. "This is what our nation was founded on," she said.

But the parents who filed the suit complain of the harm to their families, alleging they are made to feel like outsiders.

Karlton wrote in his order that those parents "have standing to challenge a practice that interferes with their right to direct their children's religious education."

If he issues an injunction barring recitation of the pledge, that would remedy the harm alleged by the parents and students, Karlton said.

Resolving the issue of harm also prevents Karlton from ruling on whether the phrase "under God" is constitutional, because the plaintiffs have not shown that the presence of those words harm them in some way beyond their children's experiences at school.

The parents also claim in the suit that they are subjected to recitation of the pledge at school board and other governmental meetings. But Karlton rejected those claims, saying the parents are complaining about policies and practices that do not require their participation.

The Supreme Court and the 9th Circuit have applied the coercion test and the "outsider" status claim with great restraint, the judge noted, recognizing them only in the context of children who are more likely to be pressured and negatively impacted. Adults are free to enter and leave public meetings at will, he pointed out.

Based on that reasoning, Karlton dismissed the part of the suit challenging the phrase "under God" and dropped from the lawsuit state and federal defendants, leaving only the three districts.

And, as the Supreme Court found last year, Karlton ruled that Newdow, who is the plaintiffs' attorney in the current lawsuit as well as a plaintiff, again has no standing to sue. Newdow was out of the state and could not be reached for comment Wednesday.

The other parents in the suit are not being named, and instead are using the pseudonyms Doe and Roe.

Jan and Pat Doe have a seventh-grader in an Elk Grove school. They are atheists and say their child is as well.

The Does contend their child "has been forced to experience the recitation of the pledge that has been led by public school teachers to the class and at assemblies. Plaintiff Doe child has suffered harassment by other students due to Doe child's refusal to participate in the pledge."

Jan Roe has two children, one a third-grader in the Elverta Joint Elementary School District and the other a kindergartner at a Rio Linda school. Jan Roe is an atheist who denies the existence of God, and his third-grader is a pantheist, who denies the existence of a personal God, according to Karlton's order.

The third-grader "has been forced to experience the recitation of the Pledge of Allegiance in her classes and has been led by her teachers in her class and at assemblies in reciting the pledge," the order says. The kindergartner has had similar experiences, it says.

State Superintendent of Public Instruction Jack O'Connell expressed disappointment in Karlton's ruling.

"Reciting the Pledge of Allegiance at the start of the school day is one of our country's great traditions and is an appropriate expression of patriotism to our country for students to learn and practice," O'Connell said.

About the writer:

  • The Bee's Denny Walsh can be reached at (916) 321-1189 or dwalsh@sacbee.com.

  Comments  

Videos

Five dead and multiple injured in Aurora, IL shooting

Watch this Placer County Sheriff K9 practice retracing a deputy’s steps

View More Video

Trending Stories

‘Just please stop coming up here.’ Sierra travel can wait, officials say, as more snow moves in

February 16, 2019 03:40 PM

One dead in Tahoe City shooting, Placer County Sheriff’s Office says

February 16, 2019 05:58 PM

Home sales have dropped sharply in Sacramento. See how that’s affecting prices in your neighborhood

February 16, 2019 03:00 AM

‘Especially De’Aaron’: What Celtics star Kyrie Irving said about Kings’ De’Aaron Fox

February 16, 2019 03:17 PM

Williams CHP officer stabbed during traffic stop on Interstate 5 in Colusa County

February 16, 2019 05:06 PM

Read Next

Denny Hamlin cruises to 2nd Daytona 500 victory in 4 years

NASCAR & Auto Racing

Denny Hamlin cruises to 2nd Daytona 500 victory in 4 years

By JENNA FRYER AP Auto Racing Writer

    ORDER REPRINT →

February 17, 2019 06:23 PM

Denny Hamlin did it again at Daytona and won NASCAR's biggest race of the year for the second time.

KEEP READING

Sign Up and Save

#ReadLocal

Get six months of free digital access to The Sacramento Bee

SUBSCRIBE WITH GOOGLE

MORE LATEST NEWS

10-year-old Girl Scout assaulted at Redding Walmart while selling cookies

Crime - Sacto 911

10-year-old Girl Scout assaulted at Redding Walmart while selling cookies

February 17, 2019 05:47 PM
Lincoln man arrested after police find him with headlamp, two-way radio

Crime - Sacto 911

Lincoln man arrested after police find him with headlamp, two-way radio

February 17, 2019 05:08 PM

Local

Traffic in Sierra at standstill following weekend of snow

February 17, 2019 03:39 PM
The Latest: Smollett says no truth he played role in attack

Latest News

The Latest: Smollett says no truth he played role in attack

February 17, 2019 03:11 AM
Aurora shooter’s permit was revoked but gun wasn’t seized

National

Aurora shooter’s permit was revoked but gun wasn’t seized

February 17, 2019 08:26 PM
Ex-FBI official: ‘Crime may have been committed’ by Trump

Latest News

Ex-FBI official: ‘Crime may have been committed’ by Trump

February 17, 2019 06:36 PM
Take Us With You

Real-time updates and all local stories you want right in the palm of your hand.

Icon for mobile apps

The Sacramento Bee App

View Newsletters

Subscriptions
  • Start a Subscription
  • Customer Service
  • eEdition
  • Vacation Hold
  • Pay Your Bill
  • Rewards
Learn More
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Newsletters
  • News in Education
  • Photo Store
Advertising
  • Place a Classified Ad
  • Place a Legal Notice
  • Place a Digital Ad
  • Place a Newspaper Ad
Copyright
Commenting Policy
Corrections Policy
Privacy Policy
Terms of Service


Back to Story