Sacramento Bee Logo

Property owners in high-risk fire zones should pay more for fire insurance | The Sacramento Bee

×
  • E-edition
    • Customer Service
    • SacBee Rewards
    • About Us
    • About Us
    • Contact Us
    • Apps
    • Mobile & Apps
    • Twitter, Facebook, Google+, YouTube
    • News in Education (NIE)
  • Newsletters

    • Sacramento Region
    • Arena
    • City Beat
    • Crime
    • Local Govt Salary Database
    • The Homeless
    • Marcos Bretón
    • Transportation
    • Education
    • Environment
    • Health & Medicine
    • Traffic Conditions
    • Weather
    • Communities
    • Elk Grove
    • Folsom/El Dorado
    • Roseville/Placer
    • Yolo
    • Sports
    • Kings
    • NBA News
    • 49ers
    • Giants
    • Oakland A's
    • High School Sports
    • Joe Davidson
    • More Sports
    • Raiders
    • NFL News
    • MLB News
    • River Cats
    • Soccer
    • Colleges
    • Golf
    • Autos Racing
    • Politics
    • Capitol Alert
    • State Workers
    • The California Influencer Series
    • Local Elections
    • PoliGRAPH
    • State Worker Salary Database
    • Legislative Gifts
    • Local Elections
    • California Elections
    • Election Endorsements
    • Election 2018
    • Voter Guide
    • Investigations
    • Data Tracker
    • Public Eye
    • Afghan Refugees
    • Nursing Homes
    • Opinion
    • Editorials
    • Election Endorsements
    • Viewpoints
    • Influencers Opinion
    • California Forum
    • Letters to the Editor
    • Submit a Letter
    • Jack Ohman
    • Editorial Board
    • Entertainment & Life
    • Arts & Theater
    • Books
    • Home & Garden
    • Movies
    • Music
    • Outdoors
    • Pets
    • Travel
    • More Entertainment
    • Events Calendar
    • Horoscopes
    • Comics
    • Puzzles
    • TV Listings
    • Sacbee Rewards
    • Food & Drink
    • Restaurants News & Reviews
    • Restaurant Directory
    • Cooking & Recipes
    • Beer
    • Wine
    • Appetizers Blog
    • California
    • Big Valley
    • Marijuana
    • Wildfires
    • Water & Drought
    • Lottery
    • Business
    • Real Estate
    • Market Summary
    • Cathie Anderson
    • Nation & World
    • National
    • World
    • Technology
    • Family
    • Celebrities
    • TV news
    • Weird News
    • Video Break
    • News Obituaries
    • Death Notices
    • FAQ
    • ObitMessenger
    • In Memoriam

    • The Sacramento Bee Store
    • Golf Card
    • Farm to Fork Dining Card
  • Jobs
  • Moonlighting
  • Cars
  • Homes
  • Classifieds
  • Legal Notices
  • Place an Ad
  • Advertise
  • Mobile & Apps

Soapbox

Property owners in high-risk fire zones should pay more for fire insurance

By Ian Adams Special to The Bee

    ORDER REPRINT →

December 26, 2017 01:11 PM

Disasters can make unlikely political bedfellows.

Confronted by a historically unprecedented year of wildfires, Placer County Supervisor Jennifer Montgomery, who represents the county’s 5th district which stretches from Auburn to Lake Tahoe, has teamed up with Sen. Ricardo Lara, D-Bell Gardens, a candidate for insurance commissioner, to spearhead the creation of an expansive wildfire risk subsidy regime sure to leave the state less prepared to respond to disasters than it is today. (“As California burns in December, this legislation could protect homeowners,” Viewpoints Dec. 26).

The two want to prevent insurers from considering wildfire loss experience in the creation of property insurance rates and to restrict the ability of insurers to protect their policyholders by limiting their exposure in areas of heightened risk – moves sure to drive up insurance rates of those living in less risky areas.

California’s natural environment is changing and becoming more fire-prone. But insulating those at risk from the impacts of this shift from the true cost of the risks that they now confront cuts against California’s otherwise enlightened approach to climate awareness championed by policymakers like Lara.

Sign Up and Save

Get six months of free digital access to The Sacramento Bee

SUBSCRIBE WITH GOOGLE

#ReadLocal

In Placer County, where wildfire risk is high, there is simply no doubt that property owners should pay more for insurance than those in low risk zones, a state of affairs which is a matter of principled personal responsibility that the electoral conservatism of Placer County should stoically embrace.

But Montgomery’s op-ed in The Sacramento Bee fails to differentiate between the severity presented by the risk to different areas. She makes the case that those residents who do the right thing and defend their homes against the threat of fire should – by right – receive a discount on their insurance rates. Yet she calls for rates to be frozen and high-risk products to remain in place in the event of a wildfire.

In other words, Montgomery is demanding that businesses extend discounts, while restricting their ability to recoup the costs. The only way that the state can allow that to occur without stumbling upon a constitutional takings challenge is for insurers to charge non-risk-based rates to others elsewhere. That arrangement is the personification of the subsidies that Placer County policymakers regularly rail against.

Montgomery is on to something when she states that “insurance providers must be required to set and adjust premiums based on an understanding of the real risk to the properties they insure.”

The largest obstacle to a scenario in which insurers can actually set rates based on the real risk to properties they insure is Proposition 103. That 1988 law has stifled product innovation and flexibility in a manner that effectively forestalls insurers from adjusting rates in a way that could serve consumers in areas of high wildfire risk. Because of Proposition 103, what can be made to work imperfectly in other states will have a hugely costly effect on the Golden State.

Ian Adams, associate vice president of state affairs in Sacramento with the R Street Institute, a free-market think tank, iadams@rstreet.org.

  Comments  

Videos

Homeless in Sacramento

Universal health care backers protest Assembly session

View More Video

Trending Stories

Gavin Newsom says California plans to sue Donald Trump over national emergency declaration

February 15, 2019 10:32 AM

Will ‘basic income’ become the California norm? Stockton starts $500 no-strings payments

February 15, 2019 03:30 AM

El Niño officially arrives: Rising rivers bring flood warnings to Sacramento, Yolo

February 14, 2019 12:21 PM

Interstate 80 closed in both directions amid whiteout conditions and collisions

February 14, 2019 07:44 PM

Does this school trip cross line between church and state? Some Sacramento parents say yes

February 14, 2019 03:30 AM

Read Next

We must do more to support gun control efforts, pressure more companies to step up

Soapbox

We must do more to support gun control efforts, pressure more companies to step up

By Bob Weiss Special to The Bee

    ORDER REPRINT →

January 20, 2019 12:01 AM

Californians should defend responsible members of the private sector who stand up for gun safety and state leaders should pressure more companies to follow the examples of Citigroup, Bank of America, Dick’s and Walmart.

KEEP READING

Sign Up and Save

#ReadLocal

Get six months of free digital access to The Sacramento Bee

SUBSCRIBE WITH GOOGLE

MORE SOAPBOX

Standardized tests unfairly favor wealthier students in college admissions

Soapbox

Standardized tests unfairly favor wealthier students in college admissions

January 15, 2019 03:00 AM
California should step up as U.S. retreats from world stage

Soapbox

California should step up as U.S. retreats from world stage

December 31, 2018 03:00 AM
Governor’s prison commutations are no substitute for criminal justice reform

Soapbox

Governor’s prison commutations are no substitute for criminal justice reform

December 27, 2018 03:00 AM
Middle class shoppers feel retail stores’ decline most keenly at Christmas

Soapbox

Middle class shoppers feel retail stores’ decline most keenly at Christmas

December 21, 2018 03:00 AM
Supervisor Frost: Let’s get past name-calling in Sheriff’s Department debate

Soapbox

Supervisor Frost: Let’s get past name-calling in Sheriff’s Department debate

December 17, 2018 06:03 PM
Is Kamala Harris ready for the national stage? Staff misconduct scandal raises doubts

Soapbox

Is Kamala Harris ready for the national stage? Staff misconduct scandal raises doubts

December 17, 2018 01:02 PM
Take Us With You

Real-time updates and all local stories you want right in the palm of your hand.

Icon for mobile apps

The Sacramento Bee App

View Newsletters

Subscriptions
  • Start a Subscription
  • Customer Service
  • eEdition
  • Vacation Hold
  • Pay Your Bill
  • Rewards
Learn More
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Newsletters
  • News in Education
  • Photo Store
Advertising
  • Place a Classified Ad
  • Place a Legal Notice
  • Place a Digital Ad
  • Place a Newspaper Ad
Copyright
Commenting Policy
Corrections Policy
Privacy Policy
Terms of Service


Back to Story