Birthright citizenship strengthens America. Just look at my family and friends

Sadly, at a time when our country is mourning the loss of 11 hate crime victims, President Donald Trump again missed an opportunity to bring us together as a country. Instead, he chose to create even more division by dehumanizing the children of immigrants, attacking the Constitution and ignoring the Bill of Rights in the process.

Birthright citizenship is well established by the courts, Congress and the Constitution. By vowing to end that right by an executive order, the president is clearly continuing to use children as political pawns to create a distraction from current events and his support of nationalism.


Trump argues that immigrants come to America to take rather than give, which I personally know is completely false. As a naturalized citizen born in Mexico, it gives me great pride to have witnessed many of my friends and my younger family members – whose parents were undocumented farm workers and who became citizens when they were born here – get an education, become successful and contribute to our country.

My younger sister, for example, was born to an undocumented mother at Woodland Memorial Hospital. She grew up to earn an engineering degree from Sacramento State, buy a home and establish a successful career building affordable housing in our region. Surely, she is not a drain or threat to our nation?

Eric Guerra new.JPG
Eric Guerra

But let’s set aside the endless lists of accomplishments by Americans born to immigrants -- those who have helped build this country, feed its citizens and defend it in wars. This is about more than Trump targeting a population who cannot speak for themselves. This is another divisive move towards xenophobia and hate.

I remember the vilification of immigrants in the 1980s and ’90s, when campaign ads filled TV screens with images of “illegals” crossing the border. I would hear my classmates talk about immigrants as if they were objects, not fellow students sitting next to them in class. All this hate and animosity, and yet the immigrants I knew were the ones who worked beside me in the fields, toiling through back-breaking work for long hours to help feed those who held them in so much hate.

We must end the bigotry and hate that comes out of “us” versus “them.” We all contribute to the strength and greatness of our nation.

The 14th Amendment resulted from a very bloody civil war fought over the principle of treating all people as human beings with equal respect and equal protection of the law. The Constitution and the Bill of Rights are the foundation for what makes our country great, acknowledging the humanity of every person.

The president should at least pay attention to the first sentence of the 14th Amendment, which clearly recognizes that any person born on U.S. soil is a citizen. What our country needs is leadership focused on unity, not an attempt to rewrite the Constitution. We must remember America’s founding motto – “E Pluribus Unum,” out of many, one.

Eric Guerra represents District 6 on the Sacramento City Council. He can be contacted at


The Sacramento Bee editorial board tackles the day’s biggest issues seven days a week, 365 days a year to keep you informed about California policy and politics.
We're a one-stop shop for timely, relevant viewpoints from elected officials and advocates on water, healthcare and housing and more.
Want to stay in the conversation? Support this forum for voices from across the state with a digital subscription to The Sacramento Bee.