Opinion Columns & Blogs

Editorial: Allowing cellphone calls on planes would make flying even more unpleasant

Flying can be a hassle, as many of us are about to be reminded as holiday travel hits high gear. You have to squeeze into cramped seats, jostle for space in the overhead bin and pay for nearly every onboard perk.

The last thing the government and airlines should consider is making air travel even more unpleasant by letting fellow passengers yap on their cellphones.

Yet here comes the Federal Communications Commission, proposing to let airlines decide whether to do just that.

Mercifully, one possible conclusion is to permit texting, emailing and Web surfing on mobile phones above 10,000 feet, but to continue the ban on voice conversations.

That is the right course – a compromise that gives travelers more freedom to communicate, but doesn’t create another circle of in-flight hell.

It may be tempting to let the free market rule. Supporters of allowing voice calls say airlines could compete for customers by offering quiet rows, limiting the number of conversations at any one time or designating entirely phone-free flights. While that sounds good in principle, real life is different. Plane cabins are such enclosed spaces that one loudmouth could ruin a flight.

The FCC is correct that its 22-year-old rules on mobile phones need to keep up with modern technology. It is technically feasible to let passengers use mobile phones without interfering with cellular towers on the ground, as airlines in Europe have demonstrated since the ban was lifted there in 2008. Just because the technology exists, however, doesn’t mean using it is wise.

Even before FCC commissioners voted 3-2 last week to start a 30-day public comment period on the proposed rule changes, some travelers, flight attendants and members of Congress loudly complained.

An Associated Press-GfK poll found that Americans oppose allowing voice calls on planes by a 48 percent to 19 percent margin; among frequent fliers, the opposition is even stronger – 78 percent against. Responding to their customers, the CEOs of two big airlines – Southwest and Delta – have said they don’t intend to allow voice calls, no matter what the government does.

Even if the FCC decides to proceed, it could be stopped in its tracks. Just before the commissioners acted, new Transportation Secretary Anthony Foxx announced that his department will consider using its authority to continue banning voice calls.

Also, Sens. Dianne Feinstein of California and Lamar Alexander of Tennessee introduced the Commercial Flight Courtesy Act (S 1811), which would prohibit cellphone voice calls on regularly scheduled domestic flights, but allow texting and other electronic communications.

“Keeping phone conversations private on commercial flights may not be enshrined in the Constitution, but it’s certainly enshrined in common sense,” Alexander said in a statement. “This legislation is about avoiding something nobody wants: nearly 2 million passengers a day, hurtling through space, trapped in 17-inch-wide seats, yapping their innermost thoughts.”

Enough said.


The Federal Communications Commission is accepting public comments on new rules for in-flight cellphone use. The proceeding number is 13-301.

• Call (888) 225-5322

• Fax to (866) 418-0232

• Submit online at http://apps.fcc.gov/ecfs//

• Write to Federal Communications Commission

Consumer and Governmental Affairs Bureau

Consumer Inquiries and Complaints Division

445 12th St. SW

Washington, D.C. 20554