Erika D. Smith

Trump doesn’t represent Pittsburgh or Paris on climate accord

Protesters gather outside the White House on Thursday to protest President Donald Trump’s decision to withdraw from the Paris climate change accord.
Protesters gather outside the White House on Thursday to protest President Donald Trump’s decision to withdraw from the Paris climate change accord. The Associated Press

The most bewildering part of President Donald Trump’s speech on Thursday – and there were plenty of bewildering moments – was when, in a nationalistic fervor, he blamed the Midwest for his ridiculous decision to pull out of the Paris climate accord.

“I was elected to represent the citizens of Pittsburgh, not Paris,” Trump said in his very best old-man-screaming-at-the-TV voice, while standing in the Rose Garden.

A while later, he added: “It is time to put Youngstown, Ohio; Detroit, Michigan; and Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania; along with many, many other locations within our great country before Paris, France. It is time to make America great again.”

Youngstown? Detroit? Pittsburgh?!

In response, the mayor of Pittsburgh, Bill Peduto, quickly tweeted: “I can assure you that we will follow the guidelines of the Paris Agreement for our people, our economy & future.”

He wasn’t alone. Within hours, the mayors of 68 cities representing 38 million Americans in both red and blue states had published a letter declaring their intent to defy Trump’s decision to exit the Paris accord. They call themselves the Mayors National Climate Action Agenda.

That’s different from the United States Climate Alliance, formed to unite the states in defiance of Trump. It’s the brainchild of Gov. Jerry Brown and the governors of New York and Washington. There’s also another group, this one of cities, states, universities and corporations, that plans to make a separate pledge to the United Nations to uphold the emissions targets of the Paris accord.

By Friday, the group of mayors had grown to 150, including Sacramento’s Darrell Steinberg.

“We will continue to lead,” they wrote. “We are increasing investments in renewable energy and energy efficiency. We will buy and create more demand for electric cars and trucks. We will increase our efforts to cut greenhouse gas emissions, create a clean energy economy, and stand for environmental justice. And if the president wants to break the promises made to our allies enshrined in the historic Paris agreement, we’ll build and strengthen relationships around the world to protect the planet.”


No matter what Trump says, his brand of economic nationalism does not represent the Midwest when it comes to climate change and the benefits of the clean energy economy. That’s because most people in the Midwest live in cities that have worked hard to transform their economies after years of getting creamed by declining old-school manufacturing businesses.

Take Pittsburgh. That’s the Pennsylvania city that Silicon Valley’s Uber chose for an initial trial of its driverless cars. It’s also a tech hub that long ago shifted away from its industrial roots. It is home to Carnegie Mellon University, which is known globally for its robotics and computer science programs.

Or Detroit. Admittedly slow to shrug off its manufacturing roots, it’s now a hub for the development of autonomous electric vehicles, working with and competing with California tech companies to be the first to stake a real claim in that space.

Or Youngstown. Once it was a booming industrial bastion of Ohio. Now there’s talk of making money off the growing renewable energy industry. On Thursday, Mayor John A. McNally said: “Nothing about the U.S. withdrawal would seem to indicate any form of job creation for the city of Youngstown.”

Even in Vice President Mike Pence’s home state of Indiana, South Bend’s Mayor Pete Buttigieg tweeted: “One of SB’s best job creators is a solar company. One of SB’s worst problems in 2016 was a climate disaster. All climate change is local.”

The people who live in these cities sitting in these swing states don’t want to go back to working in some coal mine or to give up their manufacturing job in next-generation clean tech.

Trump says the Midwest is with him on this. Don’t believe the hype.

Erika D. Smith: 916-321-1185, @Erika_D_Smith