It turns out CalPERS isn’t quite ready to take up the tobacco habit after all.
The big California pension fund Wednesday unexpectedly postponed a plan, adopted two days earlier, to launch an extensive study of whether it should reinvest in tobacco company stocks. Instead, the CalPERS investment committee will discuss the issue again May 16, said CalPERS spokeswoman Rosanna Westmoreland.
On Monday, the investment committee voted to begin a 12- to 24-month study of the pluses and minuses of tobacco investments. The vote followed a consultant’s report saying the California Public Employees’ Retirement System had sacrificed $3 billion in profits by deciding in 2001 to dump its tobacco holdings.
The investment committee consists of every CalPERS board member. As a result, approval by the full board usually is a formality. But this time it wasn’t. The representative for State Treasurer John Chiang, who opposed Monday’s decision, asked investment committee chairman Henry Jones to hold off until next month. Jones, who is also vice president of the full board, agreed.
“No public pension fund should associate itself with an industry that is a magnet for costly litigation, reputational disdain and government regulators around the globe,” Chiang said later Wednesday in a prepared statement.
Even the suggestion that CalPERS would reinvest in tobacco has sparked controversy. The pension fund is an outspoken advocate of socially responsible investing, and it also has a separate role as a health insurance provider to its 1.6 million members.
CalPERS officials have stressed that the study approved Monday wouldn’t commit the fund to jumping back into tobacco stocks.