See architectural gems in Northern California with storied past — $2.5M for both
A pair of historic, turn-of-the-century homes sharing a single lot in the heart of downtown Petaluma, California, have hit the market for $2.5 million.
The listing offers a buyer the “opportunity to cherish the history of days gone by, the epitome of turn-of-the-century workmanship, and the architectural significance of a Brainerd Jones masterpiece,” according to the property description.
The quarter-acre property includes:
▪ A stately 1902 Georgian Revival mansion (#10) designed by Jones, the renowned architect who designed such Petaluma landmarks as Petaluma Carnegie Library, Mystic Theater and McNear Building addition—all of which are visible from the property, according to research by local historian Katherine J. Rinehart which was included in the marketing materials.
The three-story home was commissioned by the Cavanagh family, headed by John W. Cavanagh, founder of Cavanagh Lumber. Cavanagh provided construction materials for many of Sonoma County’s earliest buildings.
Cavanagh served as city marshal, city recorder and justice of the peace. He was active in Petaluma fraternal organizations, including the Masons and Knights Templar.
Spanning 4,100 square feet, the residence is highlighted by original artisan redwood millwork, a spectacular and elegant foyer, rich hardwood floors, hand-carved columns and pocket doors, all of which are meticulously preserved.
Five ensuite bedrooms and seven total bathrooms provide plenty of room for a large family or numerous guests, the property listing notes.
▪ A charming, two-story 1912 Craftsman cottage (#8) , which replaced a home occupied by John E. Cavanagh’s parents and siblings for at least 40 years.
Sitting adjacent to No. 10, the home provides three bedrooms and three baths spanning more than 2,000 square feet of living space. The home is set apart by an enclosed front porch and original redwood details throughout.
The two homes — at 8 and 10 Keller Street — share a backyard anchored by a grand persimmons tree, lawn, gardens and an expansive terrace.
From 1997 to 2003, the property was managed as the Cavanagh Inn.
Colleen Mahoney bought the two houses in 2003, according to public property records.
Rob Sullivan of Coldwell Banker Realty is the listing agent.
