Shaikin: MLB must take advantage of 2028 Olympics platform. It shouldn't be so draconian about it

For years, as stars such as Shohei Ohtani and Bryce Harper pleaded for the chance to play in the Los Angeles Olympics, and for Major League Baseball to back up its talk of growing the game internationally by participating in the world's greatest sporting festival, the league was reluctant: Would the owners truly benefit from shutting down the season for a week and lending their best players to an event beyond their control?

Now that MLB is on board, the league wants the players to make an extraordinary commitment to back up their talk: If you're selected to play in the Olympics, you must play. Or else.

The "or else" is not rhetorical. If a player is not on the injured list and is selected for the Olympics but declines to participate, the player would be subject to fine and/or suspension. In addition, the players would be ineligible to play for the first 14 days when the season resumes after the Olympics, according to a proposal from the commissioner's office to the players' union and obtained by The Times.

Under a tentative MLB plan, the first half of the 2028 season would end on July 9, with the All-Star Game on July 11. The Olympic baseball competition would start on July 13, with the second half of the season starting on July 21.

So as to discourage placement on the injured list as a way to avoid playing in the Games, a player selected for the Olympics but on the injured list as of July 9 would be excused, but he could not be reinstated to his team's major league roster until Aug. 4, even if he had recovered from the injury before then.

"We went down the road on LA 2028 because we saw it as a unique opportunity to market the sport with our very, very best players," Commissioner Rob Manfred said Tuesday in a meeting with the Baseball Writers Assn. of America.

"It is a disruptive undertaking for us … If we're disrupting an entire season and we're going to undertake that effort, we want our very best out there, so that people see how great our game really is."

The league also does not want to undermine its All-Star Game, and it is reasonably foreseeable that some players might wish to skip the All-Star Game for a two-day summer break if they are going to play the next week at the Olympics.

In that scenario, under its proposal, the league would have the right to declare the player ineligible for the Olympics, and the player would be subject to fine and/or suspension as well as ineligibility for the first 14 days of the second half.

Bruce Meyer, the executive director of the players' union, said the MLBPA plans a counterproposal.

"They want to make it mandatory for players who are selected to appear at the All-Star Game and the Olympics," Meyer said Tuesday. "The proposals that they made in terms of what the discipline would be, the ramifications if a player doesn't want to do that, in our view, are extreme."

To use a Dodgers example, Yoshinobu Yamamoto was selected for this year's All-Star Game, but Dodgers manager Dave Roberts said last week that he would not pitch.

Given that situation in 2028, if Yamamoto wished to pitch for Japan, he would have to be available for the All-Star Game. If not, Japan could lose him for the Olympics, and the Dodgers could lose him for his first two starts of the second half.

Meyer said the union is in "a very early stage of discussions" with the league. It is unclear how much time might be needed to resolve the issue, as well as what Meyer called "travel and accommodation" issues, which involve LA28.

It also is uncertain how long MLB would be willing to wait before committing to an All-Star site and date, although the league moved the 2021 game from Atlanta to Denver three months before the game date. San Francisco is expected to host the 2028 game, in large part because Los Angeles is a short flight away for an Olympic competition that would start two days later.

It is clear, however, that the league is getting tired of not always securing participation from marquee players in marquee events. The "you can't pitch in the All-Star Game if you pitched on the previous Sunday" rule was intended to protect pitchers.

"It's clear to me that teams are managing their pitching in a way to take advantage of the Sunday pitcher rule," Manfred said. "I do think it's really important that we always re-evaluate our approach to the All-Star Game in order to get the very, very best players that can participate in that game."

The World Baseball Classic was a smashing success this year, even as the United States started a rookie pitcher in the championship game. Do we really need to mandate player participation in the Olympics, especially since so many great players already have said they want to be there?

"The WBC takes place at a point in time that the players are just beginning to ramp up for the season," Manfred said. "There's a whole host of reasons why, at that point in the calendar, players might not be ready to play.

"In contrast, the schedule for the Olympics is going to cover days that players otherwise would be playing in major league games - if they're not on an injured list, they'd be out there playing. That is a huge difference."

In another column, we could argue the merits of moving the final round of the WBC - the semifinals and championship game - to July, when players "otherwise would be playing in major league games." That would grow the game, too.

But that is for another day. It would be absurd for MLB to miss out on the global marketing platform that is the Olympics. The issues MLB raises are legitimate; the solutions need not be so draconian.

The opening ceremonies in Los Angeles take place two years from Tuesday. The Olympics have taught us this about boycotts: No matter how worthy the cause, no one pays attention once the Games start. The Soviet Union boycotted the L.A. Games in 1984, and we had a grand time without the Russians.

No one cares if you're not there. In MLB, a star-studded core wants to be there. Seize the moment.

This story originally appeared in Los Angeles Times.

Copyright 2026 Tribune Content Agency. All Rights Reserved.

This story was originally published July 14, 2026 at 12:14 PM.