Get out your No. 2 pencils; it’s time for a multiple-choice exam. Which NFL quarterback has a sub-83 passer rating, has a terrible touchdown-to-interception ratio and is among the bottom 10 rated passers?
A. Colin Kaepernick
B. Andrew Luck
C. Peyton Manning
D. Cam Newton
Sorry, it was a trick question. The answer is E, all of the above. But if asked, “Which of these quarterbacks’ teams is in the division cellar?”, the answer would have been clear: A.
Not only do the others have better records, their teams lead their divisions, and Manning’s Broncos and Newton’s Panthers are undefeated.
Which is to say: A lot more than bad quarterback play has sunk the 49ers this season.
Kaepernick likely has no future in San Francisco beyond this year, and there’s a good chance he’ll be benched before the end of the season. But how does someone go from winning four of six playoff games – three of them on the road – to having to be defended in a players-only meeting?
Kaepernick clearly cannot carry a bad team out of the basement. But what quarterback could under these circumstances?
78.4 Cam Newton’s passer rating for 6-0 Carolina
The 49ers have a rickety offensive line, a pushover defense and little depth at running back, and now a whisper campaign is undermining Kaepernick. As with Alex Smith before him, the 49ers have failed Kaepernick more than he’s failed them.
When he was negotiating his contract last year, Kaepernick made it clear he was willing to accept less than top-of-market value if the team would use the savings to ink extensions with some of the 49ers’ other soon-to-be free agents, such as guard Mike Iupati and wide receiver Michael Crabtree.
At that time, The Associated Press reported that, according to one source, Kaepernick specifically asked, “So this structure gives us room to try extensions with my teammates, right?” He was told yes.
Maybe that was naive. The quarterback’s six-year deal didn’t necessarily free salary cap space. But the 49ers told him they needed cash for the bonuses attached to new deals, which Kaepernick’s contract, conspicuously light in fully guaranteed money, created. The 49ers readily agreed when Kaepernick and his representatives made those stipulations and nodded along when Kaepernick spoke about it afterward in a news conference.
“Part of the way the contract is written and the way it was negotiated was so they would be able to sign other players,” Kaepernick said. “That was something that my agents and the organization worked out and they felt like this was something they would be able to get other players with.”
The 49ers didn’t come close to re-signing Iupati or Crabtree. Nor did they retain free agents Frank Gore, Chris Culliver, Perrish Cox, Josh Johnson and Dan Skuta.
82.8 Colin Kaepernick’s passer rating for 2-5 49ers
Instead, they brought in Torrey Smith, Reggie Bush, Darnell Dockett, Shareece Wright, Erik Pears, Jerome Simpson, Jarryd Hayne, Nick Bellore and Philip Wheeler.
The 49ers are nearly $12 million under the salary cap, according to the National Football League Players Association, and only five teams have more space. It’s estimated they will have $41 million in salary cap space next year, according to OvertheCap.com.
For the 6-0 Panthers, Newton has completed 55.8 percent of his passes for 1,275 yards with nine touchdowns, seven interceptions and a 78.4 passer rating. He’s being talked about – by ESPN, NFL.com and The Washington Post – as a legitimate MVP candidate.
For the 2-5 49ers, Kaepernick has completed 61.4 percent of his passes for 1,453 yards with six touchdowns, five interceptions and an 82.8 passer rating.
He’s being talked about as a legitimate candidate to be benched.